Microsoft's Brandon Watson challenged several to give Windows Phone a chance and if it failed to impress, he's donate $1,000 to their favorite charity. Scott Adams, creator of Dilbert, took Brandon up on the challenge and deemed the Windows Phone a winner over his iPhone and the EVO 3D Android phone.
Molly Wood, Executive Director over at CNET, took up the challenge to see if the Windows Phone could lure her away from Android. She posted the above video rendering her verdict as a push. Molly felt that Android gave her more power and Windows Phone was more on the "friendship ladder" where she likes it but doesn't love it.
Molly found Mango to be an easy to use, attractive system. She found Zune Pass to be be "fine" and like the Skydrive concept (but not the implementation). However, the two most important features Molly is looking for in a phone is speech to text and mapping. She was disappointed to see that speech to text wasn't integrated throughout out Windows Phone and wasn't a fan of Bing's turn-by-turn directions.
While we'd love for it to be different, not everyone is going to be a Windows Phone fan. For those keeping score, Brandon's challenge has produced one winner and one push.
In viewing Molly Wood's verdict, I couldn't help but think that her Windows Phone was fighting an uphill battle. In the end, she acknowledged that some will find Windows Phones appealing but in her case, she'll stick with Android. Not because Windows Phones suck but because Android fits her needs best. And we can respect that.
Oh and if Molly is looking for someone to send her Windows Phone to, I'll be happy to get my mailing address to her.
Source: Cnet and thanks to everyone who tipped us on this!