WP7 first impressions from an Android user

We previously published an in-depth article of the experience in coming to Windows Phone 7 from Android (opens in new tab), we now have a great insight to an Android fanatic trying out a WP7 device. Phil Turpin received the device from a friend at Tracey and Matt and wrote back some comments as to how he felt about the platform.

Having just played with a WP7 phone for the last few days it's my belief that it DOES stand a chance. A good chance.I'm an Android fan, heck I'm writing this on my phone (so if you see any ridiculous typos, you know why), and I love my Android phone but WP7 has something. My initial reaction was "hey, this is crap compared to Android, I can't even customise it." But after using it for a while I see that I don't really need to. Android's great for customisation and granular control but the problem with almost all the people here (myself included) is that we're looking at this from a techie's point of view. As someone pointed out, most Android users wont even know what rooting is and likely wont even know what a task killer is. How many Android users know what Linux is let alone care that Android is Linux? Now look at how Apple have cornered the market? Simplicity. People don't have to think when using iOS. It just works (so I've been told). WP7 is trying to be like that (& it comes pretty damn close). It also looks and flows quite nicely. Now look at the kind of person who used to buy Nokia phones? Your mum, grandma etc. Do they want to root a phone? Can they be bothered with Task Killers? (Heck, do you even need one on WP7? I know I haven't. Yet). Also think about how many businesses/corporations had stock Nokia handsets in the 90's and 00's (yes, I'm aware that we've come along since then) and now think about how many businesses have an existing MS infrastructure? The Nokia/WP marriage is perfect for them. I don't think that WP7 will gain the majority spot in the market (but, sadly, I'm not infallible ;) but I think it'll be a lot more successful than most give credit for. I use Linux as my desktop & dev environment and Android for my phone and I dearly love them both however I am going to invest in a Windows Phone dev environment because I'd be stupid not to. 

A very nice take on first impressions when coming across from the Android platform, or just having a play with one of the WP7 devices. Notice how at the end of the quote, Phil mentions he would be stupid not to invest in the Windows Phone development environment? Pretty strong words echoing our thoughts as to where Microsoft could take the OS. 

Source: Tracey and Matt (opens in new tab)

Rich Edmonds
Senior Editor, PC Build

Rich Edmonds is Senior Editor of PC hardware at Windows Central, covering everything related to PC components and NAS. He's been involved in technology for more than a decade and knows a thing or two about the magic inside a PC chassis. You can follow him over on Twitter at @RichEdmonds.

  • Ha this was a good impression. I am a windows phone 7 fan girl but i also love android equally but the experience with windows phone is great and it is way to early to count them out
  • Holy **** ! I recognize your name from Engadget! I think you are following me?!?!?! lol, I had said "Will you marry me??? Trolls need not apply." lol, I find this funny!
  • So I had the HTC Evo and was ready to let it go for the Arrive! I got the Arrive and was so turned off! Not by the tiles, not by the apps, not by the screen size (which took a while to get used too), but the simple things I did on Android... multitasking! I loved it because I could of had so much **** open at the same time. On WP7 I was immediately turned off and pondered if I had done the wrong thing of buying the phone. I forgot about multitasking and enjoyed the phone. Multitasking seemed less important to me, Zune popped and my trial is ending and I will probably pay the $15/month. I wouldn't advise anyone to buy WP7 now, but wait until the summer! I love my WP7 and have thought about the Evo 3D long and hard, but I may actually not want it! I would get it if Microsoft made a new Zune with WP7, I would buy that and keep Android. If not, I think I will be staying with WP7. I do know that multitasking will be coming soon but as you can see, I am very impatient!
  • I'd read this reply twice and still can't work out if you're bashing or praising ;-)
  • For some reason I couldn't reply until now! I love the phone though, I am coming around to it more an more everyday! I think if mango is great I will be staying! Right now I am at about 80% of staying with WP7 which is high enough. I must admit the Evo 3D looks very attractive, hopefully the next batch of WP7 phones are just as tempting (I get a new phone every year).
  • I'd like to hear the impressions after using the phone for a couple months. He will miss Android like I did. MY issues isn't that I need the granularity, the issue is I need more options for volume controls. Like I need the phone to ring, but text and e-mail to vibrate. And oh, I need all sounds off except for media and alarms. I sold my HD7, but I'll still pick up the Trophy when it's release on VZW. Even though I love my Android, I miss WP7.