Skip to main content

Dark Souls III review: A newcomer faces the challenge on Xbox One

Dark Souls 3
Dark Souls 3 (Image credit: Windows Central)

Windows Central Recommended Award

Bandai Namco and From Software's Dark Souls series of action-RPGs has a reputation for being some of the toughest games around. All the talk of difficulty can be scary for new players like me. Still, I've faced my fears and devoted the last few weeks to Dark Souls III on Xbox One. Read on for our detailed review!

Return to Lothric

Dark Souls III marks the return of Dark Souls and Bloodborne director Hidetaka Miyazaki, who produced but did not directly oversee Dark Souls II. This third game is also the culmination of the series, with the dark fantasy kingdom of Lothric finally on the brink of apocalypse. Only an undead warrior known as the Ashen One can stand against the final ruin of Lothric.

The Dark Souls lore is complex and intentionally cryptic. The third game's beautiful cinematic introduction will seem inexplicable to newcomers (and even some returning players) upon first viewing. But as you proceed through the game and meet more of the ruined world's NPC inhabitants, some of the context and the overall direction of the narrative become clear. And you can always read our story primer to get a better picture of the history of Lothric leading up to Dark Souls III.

Beginning the dark journey

Dark Souls III Xbox One

Dark Souls III (Image credit: FromSoftware Inc)

Players begin by creating an Ashen One, customizing his or her appearance, class, and starting relic. The game lets you choose a few different stock skin colors, none of them black. Considering Dark Souls' international appeal, there really should be a black preset. Luckily, you can manually edit the colors to recreate any real-life or fictional skin tone you like.

The choice of classes will affect your starting stats and abilities. For instance, a high strength class like the Knight or Warrior will be able to wield swords and wear equipment that a magic-focused class couldn't equip at the start. But a Sorcerer or Cleric can equip spells right off the bat, giving them a different set of tools with which to face enemies.

Even though deciding on a class at the start can be confusing since you won't know the game yet, don't fret too much over it. The ability to use equipment and spells is all tied to stats like Strength, Dexterity, and Attunement. Like Stranger of Sword City, you get to assign your own stat points when leveling up. So a melee fighter can eventually learn spells and vice versa if that suits your play style and growth path.

Skillful Combat

Dark Souls III Xbox One

Your Ashen One awakens in a watery graveyard. Scattered messages along the ground impart the basics of combat, something you'll spend the entirety of the game mastering. Dark Souls III's combat truly is deep, but also challenging in a way not seen in many other games.

You can swing at enemies with a fast attack and slow one. You also have the choice of switching between one-handed and two-handed weapon wielding on the fly. This grants access to a different set of moves, including weapon-specific abilities new to this entry. But two-handing prevents access to your shield – always a trade-off.

Defense is a primary requirement for success in Dark Souls III. Unlike many other action games, you can't just run up and combo enemies and expect to win. They will always strike back after a few hits (unless stunned or killed), usually initiating a devastating combo of their own. You generally can't take many hits without dying, so you have to play cautiously and avoid becoming overconfident.

Shields can block many enemy attacks, preventing some or all physical or magical damage. Shield use consumes a lot of Stamina, though. Because physical attacks need Stamina as well, you could find yourself unable to attack when blocking too much. Rolling out of the way generally requires less stamina. But the extensive and sometimes difficult to predict arcs of enemy attacks can be tough to safely roll away from – you're never especially safe from harm in Dark Souls.

Dark Souls III Xbox One

Parrying attacks (hitting the Parry button at just the right time) is also an option for advanced players. A successful parry allows players to launch an extra-powerful counterattack. Watching and learning enemy movement and attack timing to such a great extent would be an annoying requirement for less hardcore players. To Dark Souls III's credit, you can completely ignore parries and still make it through the game.

Certain monsters and predators can still be challenging to face at close range, even after facing them many times. Thankfully ranged bows and crossbows will make many opponents much easier to kill. Arrows can lure enemies away from their brethren, soften them up before they get close enough to fight back, or even kill them from complete safety.

For instance, the dragon perched atop the High Wall of Lothric, the second area, poses an extreme threat at close range. But you can take it down without suffering a single singe by simply standing just beyond the range of its fire breath and bombarding it with a few dozen arrows. A few other minibosses throughout the game can be dealt with in the same way.

Spells presumably work similarly, providing ranged attack options as well as healing and other effects. My character build can't use spells due to their stat requirements, but magic will play a key part in many Ashen One's arsenals.

Death Penalty

Dark Souls III Xbox One

A popular view of Dark Souls is that it punishes players for not being good enough. Take too many swings at an enemy or fail to block or dodge after attacking and it might be curtains for you, after all. Dying has always imposed a penalty as well, so it's hard to say Dark Souls doesn't dole out punishment. Then again, every game has some kind of death penalty or other. Without those penalties, death has no meaning and combat has no challenge.

When you die in Dark Souls III, a few things happen:

  • You return to the last Bonfire visited.
  • Any Souls collected before your death remains on the ground where you died.
  • Your maximum health drops forty percent (this penalty does not stack when dying again) and you lose the ability to summon or be summoned by other players.

A key difference from past games is that your Ashen One does not become "Hollow" (inhuman) upon death, thus avoiding some of the penalties associated with Hollow form. The character simply loses Enkindled (also known as Embered) status, the power of the Lord of Cinder. Players can still become Hollow, but it's more of a choice than a consequence this time out.

The health you have after dying is your real maximum health; Enkindlement just provides bonus health for not having died since becoming Enkindled. You can restore that status by either consuming an Ember (an initially rare item that can eventually be bought from a shopkeeper) or defeating any boss.

Although you can get by without the bonus health Enkindlement imparts, it is specifically required to take part in multiplayer, which we'll describe shortly.

Bonfires

Dark Souls III Xbox One

As for Bonfires, they act as checkpoints and fast travel locations. Because you can die more easily than in other games, Bonfires really are a big deal. Finding a new one means that you won't have to retread as much ground (and face the enemies along the way) if and when you get struck down. Resting at Bonfires also replenishes your health and Estus Flasks (items that refill health or magic) and repairs weapons, preventing them from breaking and becoming unusable.

The closer you died to a bonfire, the more likely you'll be able to recover the Souls you dropped as well. Souls obtained from items or killing enemies act as both XP and currency at the Firelink Shrine, the game's hub area. The Firekeeper there can use them to level up your Ashen One, whereas the shopkeepers accept them as payment for equipment, items, and spells.

Souls dropped upon death remain at the site of death until collected or you die again. Should you die again, those Souls disappear forever. Thus dying with a high volume of Souls can be devastating. Still, I'd never call it overly punishing. You just have to be careful during fights, try not to carry too many souls in dangerous areas, and do your best to recover them after death.

Finally, Bonfires allow players to fast travel to any other Bonfire they have reached. Not only can you get around faster that way, but it's also the best way to arrive at the Firelink Shrine to spend your Souls. The fewer souls you carry at one time, the less you have to lose when overcome by assailants.

Multiplayer

Dark Souls III Xbox One

Dark Souls III doesn't have a separate multiplayer mode. Rather, players interact with and meet each other through more unique means. For instance, you'll often come across cryptic messages left by other Ashen Ones. These typically provide hints and words of encouragement, though some have a more deceptive nature. You can rate messages as good or bad, or simply ignore them.

PvP comes in the form of Invasions. Now and then, another player will enter your game as a phantom and try to kill you. You'll only receive friendly and unfriendly visitors while Enkindled, so Invasions aren't a constant threat. They do provide rewards for whoever wins the battle, not to mention a jolt of unexpected excitement while adventuring.

Co-op works even more differently than other games. Players who want to visit someone else's game must use an item to cast a Soul Sign on the ground, usually near a Bonfire or boss location. That sign then appears in the games of some Enkindled adventurers. If they choose to interact with the sign, it will summon the visitor for some co-op.

Dark Souls III Xbox One

Visiting another player's game allows you to experience areas and practice against enemies and bosses with minimal risk – Phantoms don't drop Souls when killed. The phantom earns a reduced portion of the Souls from each kill. And if the team succeeds in defeating a boss, the visitor gets his or her Ember restored too.

Joining the game of a friend was always a difficult process in past Dark Souls games. From Software simply didn't want gamers playing with people they know. Thankfully the developer finally relaxed on that no-friends policy in Dark Souls III. You can now set a password for your game, and only the signs of people who know the password will show up.

If you struggle with Dark Souls III's difficulty, cooperative multiplayer is an excellent way to make things easier. Whenever you run into trouble, all you need to do is consume an Ember and then summon a friend or stranger for help. Many players prefer a more solitary Souls experience, but co-op is always there for those who want it.

Achievements

Dark Souls III Xbox One

Dark Souls III offers 43 Achievements worth a total of 1,000 Gamerscore. Many involve defeating certain bosses, some of which are optional, as well as joining specific Covenants (allegiances that affect multiplayer matchmaking and rewards).

Some involve collecting all of the spells and rings in the game, the latter of which requires at least three very thorough playthroughs. There are also Achievements for three of the game's four endings, again requiring multiple playthroughs. Luckily Dark Souls III has "New Game+" modes that let you go through the game again with everything you picked up the first time.

The final Achievement is for completing all other Achievements. That's some serious dedication!

A world not to be missed

Dark Souls III Xbox One

After leaving the Cemetery of Ash at the beginning of the game and defeating the first boss (which I covered in my initial impressions), players will reach the Firelink Shrine, a haven against the decay that threatens the entire world of Dark Souls. From there, you must use the Bonfire to travel to the next area, the High Wall of Lothric.

That's the only time you have to fast travel to reach a new destination. In every other aspect, the game world is a single, interconnected world. Each area leads to others, and many contain shortcuts that hide secrets and facilitate repeat visits.

At one point, the Ashen One will climb a tower inhabited by a giant wolf, ride a lift to the top, and do battle with a demon on the roof. From there, you can see nearly every other location in the game: the Undead Settlement, the Road of Sacrifices, the poisonous swamps of Farron Keep, and more. If you can see it, you can visit it at some point in your adventure.

The world of Dark Souls III is vast and connected. Although initially beautiful, things have since given way to a pestilent decay and ruin. Buildings crumble, plants and creatures fester with sores, and most of the original inhabitants have either died off or become monstrous shadows of their former selves. It is a world on the brink of death, reminiscent of Mid-World from Stephen King's Dark Tower novels.

Dark Souls III works so well both because of its unique and disturbing fantasy setting and the strength of its moment-to-moment gameplay. Even though I often died while exploring a new area and especially during boss battles, I never stopped loving it. The combat is just so good, every battle bristling with tension, danger, and excitement. Exploring the Kingdom of Lothric, seeking treasures, and solving its many mysteries proves just as rewarding.

One needs a certain disposition to appreciate Dark Souls III – a willingness to face setbacks and challenges and then overcome them. Don't expect to play this just like any other action-RPG. If you're going to play this game, it must be on its own terms and as it's meant to be played. That patience will be rewarded with a masterpiece, easily one of the best action and role-playing games of the year.

Pros:

  • Deep combat system that rewards skill and practice
  • Huge interconnected world filled with beauty and decay
  • Memorable and challenging boss battles
  • Multiplayer matchmaking significantly improved over previous entries

Cons:

  • Clumsy menus. Why can't we equip items from the Inventory menu?
  • Hit detection sometimes allows foes to strike through objects
  • Supposedly Dark Souls III will be the final game in the series. On the plus side, From Software will release three expansions in 2016 and 2017.

Xbox One version provided for review by Bandai Namco.

Paul Acevedo is the Games Editor at Windows Central. A lifelong gamer, he has written about videogames for over 15 years and reviewed over 350 games for our site. Follow him on Twitter @PaulRAcevedo. Don’t hate. Appreciate!

32 Comments
  • Pvp is trash compared yo DS2 no poise. Campaign is ok pvp is 4 vs 1
  • The only way to have 4 invaders is by using an object that lets you have 3 allies.
  • Just Invade someone on pontif sylyvan bonfire you will see
  • There is poise, the problem is that its broken right now and no fix is in sight. Someone dug through the code, and the poise stat is basically disabled until you use an ability that gives you poise. Like the stomp skill on the dark sword.
  • Devs addressed this issue and said it isn't broke. Poise is working as intended. It works differently than previous games.
  • It's very silly that they refused to clarify how it works. They just left it where people think they're lying to save face.
  • Isn't it kind of unfair to give a game a perfect rating while saying that part of it is so messed up that people think the developers are lying about it? Even if you don't agree with that assessment, that you're acknowledging their actions as bad for the game, calling it a perfect-scoring game just doesn't fit in my mind well. I'm going to try to find a chance to read it tomorrow after work.
  • No game is truly perfect. There are always minor flaws, and I list a few in the review. But I don't believe in not using the maximum rating. When you do that, the next step down becomes the real maximum. For me, Dark Souls III (and the few other games I've given a 10/10) are as good as a game gets. The Poise stat issue doesn't affect my enjoyment of the game.
  • masterpiece? woooow, thats not fair. A masterpiece is something unique, never seen before. Dark Souls is a good game for a specific group of people but a masterpiece? Nope.
  • That's a definition of masterpiece, but not the only one. In any case, I just gave it a 5/5 (or 10/10) and didn't select the word our site uses to describe that rating.
  • its okay, iam not complaining just for me its not a "masterpiece". Its a good, challenging game for a very specific group of people. For them it could be 5/5 for others its 3.5/4 - just an opinion, no offense
  • Im inclined to agree with you
  • The same can be said for every game ever made.
  • Except THPS5, which is a technicaly mess of idiocy that never should have happened, and that's just a fact of what the broken mess of a game is.
     
  • But for people who enjoy a mess, those who see broken and think 'challenge', it's perfect and fun.
  • Not with a game like Tony Hawk. It's not a matter of being clunky to the point of addnig challenges, it's physically boken to the point of being unplayable. When a skater literally sinks into the half-pipe or a wall, there's no skill adjustment to avoid that, unless you were to pinpoint where the game code allows for that stuff, and then skate around those parts or something. AC: Unity is another example--the added challenge of that is hoping you don't randomly fall through the ground, not playing better than someone else.
  • Which games have you played before a Souls game that plays the same as a Souls game? I can't think of any, so that makes them unique to me.
  • But the fifth of them (when you count Demond Souls and Bloodborne) really can't be called unique. At this point, it's certainly in the realm of "iterative."
  • Dark souls series is always fun, they pack a challenge until you finishes the game for the first round. DS3 is still on my wish list :)
  • they said halo 3 was the finnial. But things change. I do wonder if thats just a marketing gimic to get people to buy it. As for this game it looks like graphicly like a work of art. great looking from what i can tell. However I am not much of one for sord fighting games. I would rather play a total war style look down then controll one guy on the field of battle. I did enjoy ryse though.  If I had played  1 and 2 i may be more likely to try 3. But I am sure someone will get this game.
  • all the negatives shows me none of you agree with my statement that someone will get this game. it goes to show most of you think no one will get this game...
  • Multiplayer doesn't work on Xbox 95% of the time. Prepare to be disappointed.
  • That has not been the experience of me or anyone I know. You might have NAT issues with your router.
  • Try turning off region restrictions
  • Try contacting Customer support on www.xbox.com via live chat or calling in. or you can try @xboxsupport on twitter and they will help you out. there are also some great forums on xbox.com where you can find information. dont hesitate to call your isp also to make sure they have xbox live working properly on your internet connection. some isps block some ports.
  • I had the same issue until I changed my NAT settings on my router to "Open" and now no problems at all.
  • The frame rate is a real struggle in the Xbox version (though Dark Souls 2 and 1 were the same) but I'm still slogging through.
  • Dark souls is great, i watched some dark souls 3 videos and streams and the game looks amazing but i didn't bought it yet. I have dark souls 1 and i never beat the game, my problem is not the difficult, i like hard games, but i think that I'm a bit lazy to manage my stats and items, these things have too much details, like a big worksheet... Maybe I'll install it again and try.. :)
  • Try not to worry about stats and items too much. Dark Souls games are more skill based than stats or items.
  • True, but it gets really fun when you level up and boost a stat a bunch.
  • I never had the time to pick the game up and play it but i watch my wife play in and i give a good 9.5 it looks pretty hard though
  • Had so much fun with this game (100% it this weekend) and now I'm having fun leaving summon signs down to help those in need on the bosses. (Nameless King is one heck of a challenge btw)!