Review: The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

Geralt in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
Geralt in The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt (Image credit: CD Projekt Red)

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is the brainchild of Polish developer CD Projekt RED. Their answer to the WRPG genre delivers a gargantuan open world weaved together with a nail-bitingly mature narrative. Witcher 3 is the end of a trilogy that follows the exploits of the superhuman Geralt of Rivia. Geralt is a witcher, who are a caste of warrior monks trained since childhood to seek out and slay monsters that plague the land and its medieval populace.

The game has sold four million copies in just two weeks and rides high in the 90s on Metacritic. If you're a fan of WRPGs, you're probably waist deep in the game's perilous Northern Kingdoms already, but if you're still unsure here are my thoughts on The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt.

Presentation

A living, breathing world

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is bloody gorgeous, with an emphasis on bloody. The game's world is heavily inspired by medieval Eastern Europe, and it displays that inspiration with class and authenticity. On Xbox One, The Witcher 3 hovers around 30 FPS and utilises dynamic scaling between 900p and 1080p which prevents slowdown during intensive moments. I haven't suffered a single instance of crashing or graphical lag, save for a pre-rendered cut-scene error that has since been patched. CD Projekt RED's technical prowess is matched only by their attention to detail.

The game's natural locations enjoy biodiversity that similar games have yet to touch.

CD Projekt RED placed a lot of emphasis on the idea that The Witcher 3 is a living, breathing world, and it's hard to suggest that they haven't delivered. The Northern Kingdoms depicted in The Witcher 3 are mind-boggling with detail. The Witcher 3's largest cities are crammed with dangerous alleyways, uncharted sewers and detailed interiors. Class divisions are clearly visible as you traverse the muck carpeted streets of Novigrad's slums, all the way up to the extravagant estates of the city's nobility. Peasants scrape out a meager existence on the outskirts, dogged by war-induced anarchy and the monsters who come to feast on the vanquished.

Border to border, The Witcher 3 is perhaps the best-looking game on the Xbox One today, and most certainly the best looking open world game. The sun touches every blade of grass, oozing warmth through the screen. The game's natural locations enjoy biodiversity that similar games have yet to approach. In a single forest scene, I counted nine separate types of plant species, four different types of songbird and the sounds of what can only be described as a frog in heat. I ended up leaving the scene running on my Xbox One for around 60 minutes, simply enjoying the ambiance, the shift from day into dusk and calm winds into a heavy storm.

From corpse ridden battlefields, golden hills, uncharted swamps, the water locked islands and untouched mountains, The Witcher 3 is a feast for the senses. I consider it, without a doubt, the most immersive game available on Xbox One today.

Setting & Story

Mature, violent and emotional

The Witcher 3 takes place roughly six months after the events of The Witcher 2. The Southern nation of Nilfgaard has invaded the Northern realms, bringing chaos, famine and slavery to those unlucky enough to live near the border. Vizima, the city where much of The Witcher 1 took place, is occupied by Nilfgaard. It's not long after the start of the game that Geralt finds himself there at the behest of Emperor Emhyr var Emreis. The Emperor wishes for Geralt to find the whereabouts of Ciri, the Imperial princess and former protégé of Geralt. Ciri is a source, which means she has genes that give her the ability to produce wildly powerful magic. Like Geralt, Ciri is trained in the Witcher arts of swordplay and monster hunting, making her incredibly hard to track down.

The Witcher games are based on an eponymously titled book series by Polish author Andrzej Sapkowski. The series is steeped in European mythology, as well as drawing on my fair continent's medieval history for its locations and setting. The height of technology enjoyed by the denizens of the North amounts to trebuchets, sailing ships and basic metallurgy. Superstition is rife, barbarous bandits prowl every dark corner and monsters encroach on every hamlet. Geralt is widely regarded as the greatest living Witcher, enjoying a degree of fame for his deeds. Only he has the abilities and skill to track down Ciri across a sub-continent beset by war, plague and roaming monsters.

The game world is meticulously consistent, adding authenticity and immersion to compliment those pristine visuals.

For me, despite having amazing presentation and gameplay, I feel that the greatest strength of The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt lie in its narrative. The game world is meticulously consistent, adding authenticity and thus immersion to compliment those pristine visuals. The voice acting is on the high-end for the most part, and the dialogue should provoke a full range of human emotion from even the most hardened hardcore gamer. Some of the dialogue is so witty that I've completely lost track of the fact I was playing a game, feeling instead like I was watching a big budget TV show.

Situations often present dialogue choices, which can influence the story at a later date. Seemingly innocuous decisions I'd made at the start of the game came back to haunt me 20+ hours in, which was equal parts surprising and gratifying. Choices aren't as dichotomic as they might be in Dragon Age or Mass Effect, mainly because Geralt's general personality is quite integral to the plot. Some fans looking for more influence over Geralt might find themselves disappointed as a result. This is very much Geralt's tale, and his sensitivity, charm, and dry wit makes the 100+-hour journey nothing short of a pleasure.

CD Projekt RED have painstakingly given weight to even the most minor side quests, many of which breathe life and history into NPCs you might only encounter once in the game. Each village has its story to tell, and the narrative governing the side quests all tie together like a gift waiting to be opened. One side quest might task you with the slaying of a wraith while another might give you clues about what led to the haunting in the first place. Many minor side quests compliment each other without being inextricably linked in this way. The questing across each location is cohesive on a level I haven't seen before in a WRPG. I sorely hope The Witcher 3 and its side quests set the standard for future RPGs to come.

Throughout The Witcher 3, you'll dive into gritty political intrigue, rescue villages from their local monsters and vanquish grand and ancient evil. Cover to cover, The Witcher 3 is an instant classic that has a little something for everyone. If you enjoy story-driven games, The Witcher 3 should be high on your list.

Gameplay

Challenging, diverse and rewarding

At its core, The Witcher 3 is an open-world action RPG, with an emphasis on story and swordplay. Most of the game takes place across 4 contained but huge open-world locations, which force you to turn back if you hit the seams. The main quest to track Ciri pulls you from location to location. Along the way you'll find NPCs in need of aid, notice boards crammed with side quests and various other features which keep play fresh. Some of the side activities involve liberating prisoners, treasure hunts for better gear and rescuing abandoned settlements from threats. These are beside mini-games like horse racing, fist fighting tournaments, and the addictive Gwent card game.

Quests take on all sorts of forms, and they're always soaked in context. I never felt bored with the Witcher 3's optional quests, as they're all deeply woven into the local narrative (as explained above). Geralt's signature monster hunting contracts take the form of investigations. Often, these quests require you to follow a monster's footprints, track their kills or follow their scent, using Geralt's super-human witcher senses. The game frequently changes the formula for the delivery of these quests, to prevent them becoming stale. Occasionally a monster killing will turn into a murder investigation, or something even more intriguing. These quests rarely feel formulaic.

Some of the game's optional objectives can become tiresome, particularly if you out-level an area's content. There's nothing forcing you to explore each and every cave, buried treasure and bandit camp on the map, but it would be nice if the rewards for doing so scaled in level along with Geralt.

Another method The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt uses to command your attention across its 40+ hour story, is through combat. Each and every monster type (and oh, there's dozens of them) demands that you use a different combat strategy. Combat consists of a heavy attack pattern, a light attack pattern, dodges, spells and other tools. Some reviewers have claimed that The Witcher 3's combat is unfair, but I'd argue that they're playing it wrong. The bestiary contains information on every monster you'll encounter in combat, offering tips on how best to fight each beast. Geralt is a witcher, and studying your enemies is consistent with the game's lore. As such, you'll find yourself learning the attack patterns of ghouls and drowners until its second nature. Groups of enemies will splatter Geralt very easily on normal difficulty, and your strategies will have to change to meet each situation. To keep things fresh, The Witcher 3 introduces variants of the same enemy types that attack differently, and human enemies are persistently diverse with their attack strategies and weapons.

Eventually, you'll have enough potions types, blade oils, bombs and talents to meet most challenges fairly easily, especially if you're a completionist. As someone who likes to hunt down every map location, I often found myself much higher level than the story quests demanded of me. Luckily, the game allows you to adjust the difficulty if it ever becomes too easy.

The only gripes I have with how the Witcher 3 plays are found in some of its side-systems. Swimming, horse riding and sailing all feel cumbersome and less intuitive than combat and general movement. Inventory management is an absolute pain, and towards the end of the game your bags will be so overflowing with quest items, herbs and other junk that it causes the UI to lag. Considering that The Witcher 1 had an auto-sort inventory button, it seems odd that it didn't make the grade for The Witcher 3. The map system also fights the player, refusing to allow you to zoom out far enough. This is particularly annoying when a quest objective is far from your present location, finding the quest marker can be like looking for a needle in a haystack. CD Projekt RED are taking feedback on how the game works and are delivering frequent patches, so I wouldn't be surprised if these UI systems become overhauled.

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is hard to fault on gameplay overall. I think I would've liked more unique set-piece boss fights like the Kayran giant squid from The Witcher 2 or the Zeugl giant squid boss fight from The Witcher 1, but it's a tiny gripe. Maybe I just have a thing for cephalopods. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is so polished it's shimmering with gameplay goodness, and it will earn a place among the greatest action RPGs without a doubt.

Final Words

An instant classic

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is simply incredible. I've looked hard for things to complain about, but it's mostly a fruitless endeavour. The quests are diverse and varied; the plot is fist-clinchingly gripping, and the combat is strategic and rewarding.

Beyond the game itself, CD Projekt RED have already provided three system updates improving the game's stability (which was near-perfect on day one). This is beside new quests and other small DLC all of which are entirely free. The game features no microtransactions, no day 1 DLC, and no platform exclusive content. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is a pure game, a true labour of love for video game development. It is an example of what a game can be without publisher meddling.

Pros:

  • Challenging, but rewarding gameplay
  • Industry leading game design
  • Gripping plot with memorable characters
  • Meaty 100+ hour content, bolstered by free DLC

Cons:

  • Inventory, maps and other menu systems are cumbersome
  • So good that it ruins real-life relationships and work productivity

The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt is among the most beautiful, majestic and engaging games on Xbox One today. I'd not hesitate to call it the best game available on Xbox One today, but those are a Witcher fan's words. If you like RPGs, you've probably already picked this up. But, fans of third person action, fantasy story telling or just good games should also buy this. It could be a long time before we see an RPG on this level again.

  • The Witcher 3 – Xbox One – 26 GB – $59.99 – Amazon Link (opens in new tab)
  • The Witcher 3 – Windows – $59.99 – Steam Link
Jez Corden
Co-Managing Editor

Jez Corden a Managing Editor at Windows Central, focusing primarily on all things Xbox and gaming. Jez is known for breaking exclusive news and analysis as relates to the Microsoft ecosystem while being powered by caffeine. Follow on Twitter @JezCorden and listen to his Xbox Two podcast, all about, you guessed it, Xbox!

50 Comments
  • Amazing game...
  • Agree. Easily the best game I've played in years!
  • Agreed. It is superb, and certainly ruining much better after the latest patch.
  • Yes, I also think that it ruining my social life much better now.
  • But which version is better? I have a very good PC gaming rig and a One. Should I go for the PC version, or does it even matter?
  • If you have a good PC, get it on PC.
  • Thanks!
  • But I want elder scrolls 6!
  • Conan o brien the clueless gamers review was enough for me!
  • That is a good review
  • Nope. I still have not bought it.
  • We had to bribe Jez to stop playing long enough to write something. Seriously...he hasn't been outside in weeks.
  • Lol, I might end up in a similar state if I get this game....
  • Awesome game, beat the main story and almost every side quest/contract. Really looking forward to the next free DLC quests/contracts and expansions (so I can get past that pesky level 37...)
  • Not sure I agree that it's the best looking game on XBone. Forza Horizon 2 and Dark Age: Inquisition both look better......... But that's my opinion.
  • I agree! Forza Horizon 2 is a phenomenally beautiful game as is Dragon Age. I prefer the design aesthetic and the lore better in Dragon Age games than Witcher though. I can't stand playing as Geralt and am thankful that I can play as a user created character in DA. Still, I'm glad the game has sold well.
  • Geralt is a badass
  • Great review. No comments at all on the achievements though?
  • Not a huge achievement hunter myself, shall bear it in mind for future reviews. Most of them are pretty easy, story based achievements. Others are combat based. The more difficult ones are probably the card collecting ones, and completing the game on the hardest difficulty - its already hard enough haha
  • I'm an achievement hunter and Witcher 3 is the only game I started without taking a look at the achievement list ever. I only knew there are difficulty achievements, so I started the game on the hardest difficulty to make it a little more challenging. It's awesome!!
  • Wrpg? Crpg? What are these subvariants of RPG games?
  • CRPG just means computer role-playing game.  WRPG is western role-playing game, as opposed to Japaneese styled games.
  • WRPG = western RPG. CRPG = computer RPGs, like Witcher 1, The types of RPGs that wouldn't work on consoles.
  • Tempted to get this but I know I will probably get addicted to playing it hours on end.... Lol.
  • Most definitely :) Still so worth it, though - so go for it!
  • I love this game!
  • I heard that it's inappropriate scenes
  • It's rated M.
  • It's rated R in Australia, but that is due to the adult nature of some scenes as well as the dismemberment.
  • I plan on buying this when my Steam controller arives at some point. Are there any graphical improvements in the pc version?
  • Is that a serious question?
  • Hairworks. Higher particle count. More NPCs on screen. Better shadows. More shadows. Better draw distance for foliage, grass and shadows. Denser grass. Better shadowing due to better AO technique on PC. Better textures due to higher rez textures on PC, higher LoD and 16xAF which does not exist on consoles.
  • God thx. And yes, it was a serious question ;-)
  • I hate this game. I hate how it's taking over my life. How many hours have I spent on meaningful quests. Admiring the in-game sunrises and sunsets. Reading every book and note that I find. Playing through the night. Damn you CD Projekt RED, why did you release this game!
  • Here is my review.
    It's fookin awesome
  • Have you played the PC version? How is it? Posted via the Windows Central App for Android
  • I haven't I'm afraid, my only PC is my trusty Surface Pro 3, and she just can't run it. :(
  • I'm still addicted to this game weeks later, I didn't think it was still possible in the current gaming era with the decline in creativity and quality.
  • Agree. Even weeks in I still encounter moments where I just pause in awe of voice acting, vistas, intelligent story telling etc etc. What a masterpiece... Heck, I find it unfathomable how a game like that is even possible with so much content and so many different outcomes!
  • Great to see you guys enjoying the game but don't forget to enjoy real life from time to time ;) Cheers
  • Real life is overrated ;)
  • I'm torn on whether to get this or not. I quit playing WoW years ago becuz it took over my life. It was the crack cocaine of gaming. I played nothing else and lost countless hours of sleep. I'm about half or a little more done with Farcry4 and I'm simply not ready for another open world game. I might just skip Witcher becuz my children, coworkers and wife don't want a Zombie walking amongst them. Plus Fallout 4 may fit in just nicely...but we'll see when it's due to be released.
  • As a 7 year WoW veteran I can safely say that this game will take over your life in the same way. It's insanely addictive. Every time I play it I'm just like "oh one more quest" then its 3am, lol. The difference is, The Witcher 3 does come to an end, unlike WoW. ;)
  • I thought it would be the best RPG in awhile too, but that Fallout 4 presentation. Don't get me wrong Witcher 3 is an amazing game imo, but 2015 is looking like a great year for games and RPGs (Pillars of Eternity was another great one).
  • Strange but for me the only good was first one. This one is so "slow", not in terms of performace, but the game itself. Opening map takes 3 sec! I have very powerful PC and playing with maximum quality. Overall game looks excellent, but I just cannot play it as every stupid move reqiured certain amount of time. Another example, you're want to sell something. Just calculate how much seconds you need to go through talking menu.
  • What exactly does a frog in heat sound like....lol. That got me.
  • ON PC, when on map, use TAB to switch between current position and objective. If pressing TAB doesn't take you anywhere on the map, switch to World Map, look to the region with the "objective" pin, click on said region then press TAB. No need for constant moving around the map to find the objective.
  • I actually played some of the main missions today! I haven't done those in a while. Of course I also did a lot of secondary quests and some contacts, hunted for Witcher gear. But I at least got through part of the main storyline!
  • Cool
  • Is it similar to Skyrim?