Despite warnings that the Titanfall 2 build on offer was in a pre-Alpha state, I've seen quite a bit of (often angry) dissent about changes Respawn have injected into the Titanfall formula.
EA often do high-profile public tests for upcoming games, with Star Wars Battlefront landing last year, and Battlefield 1 coming later in the month. As more and more of our games come with increasingly complex online features, these sorts of tests are becoming the norm, but it they also threaten to derail the hype train when treated as demonstrations of finished products.
EA and Respawn have both stated that they are listening to feedback about the changes present in Titanfall 2, and they really ought to because some of the new features do little to enhance Titanfall's beloved, blisteringly fast-paced formula.
Here are the main concerns I think Respawn need to address in Titanfall 2 before the game launches on October 28th, 2016.
1. The Titan "battery" gameplay is not good
Did you notice how weak the Titans felt in Titanfall 2? But you weren't sure why? It appears that, in Titanfall 2, the Titan mechs no longer have shield generators by default, leaving their hit points completely exposed to damage straight after spawning.
There's every chance that shield generators might be something you can fit your Titan with in the loadout screen as part of the game's RPG layer unlock system (and if you know so, drop a comment below), but if not, Respawn really needs to rethink this aspect of the game. Ignoring the idea that somehow the world of Titanfall's technology somehow got worse over time, let's analyze and speculate why Respawn might have decided to do this.
When riding an enemy Titan, you now rip out one of their batteries, taking a portion of their health and equipping it on your back like Dark Zone drops in The Division. Batteries dropped from deceased pilots or Titans are also represented on the mini map as green battery symbols, available for any player to pick up by pressing X. When you rodeo a friendly Titan, or enter your own Titan, you'll grant that mech an overshield and a health boost.
I suppose the mentality surrounding this gameplay is to make Titanfall 2 feel more team-based. If teams of co-ordinated pilots are working together to keep their friendly Titans alive, that team has a greater chance at victory. It's a nice idea, but it just wreaks havoc on Titanfall 2's pacing. It just doesn't feel particularly great to have to jump out of your Titan, scoop a battery off the floor, then jump back in. It interrupts the flow of combat, and also impacts the way Titans are balanced.
One of the first complaints I saw about Titanfall 2 was that the mechs now take way too long to become available. I feel that Respawn wanted Titans to feel more crucial, and more precious in play, particularly when combined with the awkward Duracell-collecting gameplay.
After spending the last few months with Blizzard's team-based Overwatch, the lack of strategic team play in the classic Titanfall game is pretty stark. But that's by no means a bad thing. Titanfall was a game about flying solo, running and gunning, largely ignoring what the rest of your team were doing except for the occasional opportunity to swat a player from the back of a friendly Titan. I appreciate that Respawn perhaps wanted to rectify this in some way, but I think this is a lazy way to do it, especially when it results in Titans feeling significantly weaker than they did in the previous game.
Instead, I propose that battery pick ups are optional and instead help your friendly Titans to generate their core abilities more rapidly, and perhaps give some minor Titan health regen. All Titans should have shields. This alteration would keep the battery mechanic in play, allowing co-ordinated teams to get an edge, but it wouldn't make them so critical as to interrupt the feel and flow classic Titanfall fans are accustomed to. Additionally, I would make battery extraction from enemy Titans optional as well. It sucks that you can't fire your rifle at point blank range into enemy Titan's exposed hulls anymore.
2. More wall running
In the technical test, we were granted access to two different maps with one thing in common - a disappointing lack of opportunities to wall run. Wall running is one of Titanfall's most successful, most iconic features. So awesome that Call of Duty itself attempts to emulate it. So then, why does it seem so scaled back in Titanfall 2?
Of course, perhaps the maps we were offered for the technical test just happened to be the least wall-runner friendly, but I can't think of a single map in the original Titanfall that felt anywhere near as awkward for the dedicated sci-fi parkour enthusiast. Maps in the original Titanfall were designed as such that you could wall run throughout their entirety, never touching the ground. It's simply not the case in Titanfall 2, and the franchise completely loses its identity as a result.
One presumption could be that the maps have been redesigned with the game's new sliding mechanics and grappling hook in mind, but given the fact the grappling hook is an optional piece of load out equipment, that rings a little hollow. Either these maps need to be given an injection of vertical surfaces to aid traversal, or Respawn need to make the grappling hook a default piece of equipment.
Titanfall 2 also has a decreased time to kill, which I think contributes to accusations that it feels more "Call of Duty"-like, where if you're seen first, there's almost no way to counter attack. The reduced time to kill allows you to pull off some incredible stunts, killing players in mid air and during well-timed sliding maneuvers, but it also harms wall running as a means of escape. You often leave yourself exposed to being instagibbed while wall running now, as it's so easy to die the minute you're spotted. I think boosting player's health slightly would make wall running a more viable means of traversal again, reducing the incentive to camp in a corner.
3. Map design in general
Beyond the issues with wall running, the maps we were offered in the beta seem to diverge from the lane-based 'map within a map' layouts seen in the original Titanfall. Previously, Titanfall featured lanes designated for use by Titans, interweaved with buildings and smaller areas players could use to scurry away from the game's giant, insta-killing robots. The density allowed for many wall running and parkour opportunities, but also forced Titans into conflict with each other, dissuading them from seeking out squishy pilots to stomp. This gave the game a dynamism, where Titans still felt incredibly powerful vs. pilots, but savvy players were not only able to escape very easily, but also launch counter attacks from the game's various nooks.
The two maps we were able to try were far too open, too featureless. It seems completely at odds with some of the new Titan abilities which allow you to control areas on the ground. The Scorch Titan in particular has abilities that allow him to lay thermite traps to block enemy Titans from advancing, but when the maps are so open they can just be very easily circumnavigated, what is the point in these skills? Also, the lack of features essentially corrals players into a subset of areas that become simple shooting galleries of "who saw who first." In the previous Titanfall, you had no idea where players were going to come at you from, because the maps were so sprawling with rich opportunities for wall running and vertical play. Out of the box, Titanfall 2's tech test had a CoD-like camping problem.
With only two months left until release, I doubt we'll see any major overhaul in the way the maps are structured, but from what we've seen so far, it seems like Titanfall 2's map designers have taken a gigantic leap in the wrong direction.
4. What happened to the A.I. enemies?
One of the coolest things about the original Titanfall was the army of A.I. soldiers and robots that swarmed the game's maps. On almost every mode, across every map, waves of A.I. would spawn and make Titanfall feel far more war-like than many other arena-based shooters.
Not only did the A.I. robots and soldiers add to Titanfall's atmosphere, but they also served a gameplay purpose, giving you something to shoot while hunting down enemy players, while also allowing you to reduce the spawn timer on your Titan or core ability.
Perhaps it's just an issue with the test (and if you know so, drop a comment below), but only the game's new Bounty mode saw any form of A.I. join the fray. Hardpoint and Pilot Hunter felt empty without the A.I. soldiers, which again felt like a climb down from the original vision of Titanfall.
The lack of A.I. also contributes to a reduction in the speed by which you can unlock your Titan. Respawn hotfixed the accrual speed of the Titan summoning in the middle of the test, but considering the only way to unlock your mech is now based on how many kills you get, rather than a fixed timer you can reduce, this seems overly punishing to more casual players.
5. Give us real party systems
I'm sure this is a given, but just in case it's not, Titanfall 2 needs a real party system. In the tech test, we got a glimpse at the game's new "Network" system, which allows groups of like-minded players to create a membership-based network that automatically draws people from the roster directly into a match. The present implementation is a pure nightmare.
When queuing for a match, it will automatically invite other people from the Network, but if they miss the invite message (or don't receive it at all as the result of bugs in the system), then you have to back out and try again. We spent a good thirty minutes trying to get into the same game using this system, and I'm not entirely sure why Respawn Entertainment thought this implementation would be preferable over a tried and true, basic party system, which allows you to jump into a group with friends with one leader queueing for the entire group.
Respawn appears to have already acknowledged problems with this system, but let's hope they fall back on something a little less convoluted for the full game.
Titanfall 2 does a lot right
For all my gripes, Titanfall 2 does a lot of things right. The new sliding mechanics made me feel like a super hero movie stuntman on more than one occasion, and the grappling hook aids traversal where wall running falls short. Even though I think it should be a little more forgiving, I enjoy the way Titans are accrued now, as a reward for performing the game's objectives with a "Burn Card"-like customizable ability at the half-way point. Some have decried the decreased time to kill speed in Titanfall 2, but I think it helps to pull off incredibly rewarding shots while grappling, sliding and any situation where you're moving at high speed. And hey, the game looks rather gorgeous.
There's not a lot of time left between now and Titanfall 2's launch date, but Respawn already issued a hotfix for the Titan accrual speed in the middle of the last test. That's something I would take as an encouraging sign. Will we see map overhauls? Unlikely. But we also haven't seen the full breadth of abilities available to both pilots and mechs. They could be balanced around a lot of unknown parameters.
Is there a method to Respawn's madness? I'm willing to give them the benefit of the doubt, for now. Perhaps I'm naïve.
Titanfall 2 launches on October 28th on PC, Xbox One and PS4.
See Titanfall 2 on the Xbox Store (opens in new tab)
How do you feel about Titanfall 2's pre-Alpha test? Let us know in the comments!
Jez Corden is a Senior Editor for Windows Central, focusing primarily on all things Xbox and gaming. Jez is known for breaking exclusive news and analysis as relates to the Microsoft ecosystem while being powered by caffeine. Follow on Twitter @JezCorden and listen to his Xbox Two podcast, all about, you guessed it, Xbox!
The AI enemy complaint is absurd. Many, MANY people flagged Titanfall as a failure because there wasn't enough PvP battling in the game. I, for one, did not necessarily agree, but I also thoroughly enjoyed Pilot vs. Pilot mode in the tech test. Adding more AI enemies into the game would be a horrible decision.
I think adding AI is great on all modes but also adding more pilots to the game, 5v5 6v6 is really bad choice it should be no less 10v10. Posted via the Windows Central App for Android
Star Wars Battlefront will also add some AI to balance out teams... I liked it personally
It's not absurd. The people that complain about the grunts in TF1 overlook how they add to the ambiance and over all feel to the game. They create a much more active and chaotic battlefield. TF2 felt barren in contrast. I personally LOVE the comments the grunts say during gameplay. They are halarious! Grunt 1: I hit the gym this morning, so I can go all day like this! Grunt 2: Nobody likes you...
Grunt 1: Today's my lucky day, I haven't missed a single shot. Grunt 2: That's because you haven't even pulled the trigger. Grunt 1: I'm trying to be precise!
(this might not be perfect) Grunt 1: My dad fought for the Militia, that's why I joined the Militia. Grunt 2: My dad fought for the IMC, that's why I joined the Militia. I didn't like my dad that much.
This pretty much has them all. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ayeoBzZylBM
I enjoyed the Tech Test for the most part, Titans took way too long to get (infact I only got to play with one over the whole weekend). The party system sucks in it. 5 of us came in to play, If we just joined a match, we could not add other players (COD is great at this aspect). We had to create a network, with all 5 members, THEN join a mutliplayer game. Maps, meh, ok...Knowing that this a early preview, even when you were on the plane/helicopter, the graphics looked like a 16 bit game, very poor. The maps were only a peak at one of the test ones, I hope they get better but, till we see the next preview, I will write this off as tech test levels. Bots...Meh, it's always nice to have more things to shoot at but, I would prefer more players on the map, at different levels. SO even a Noob can go in and kill a few things (and get points for it) and not get stuck with top level players, that just drop you at the spawn points. SO far, it looks like its going good...cant wait for it to release..
I agree on party and the titans take long
I'm happy they changed how rodeo works. I ran electronic smoke on all my Titan load outs because it was the easiest way to deal with rodeoing pilots. I would almost always get get killed if I jumped out to deal them myself and the cluster missile trick would do damage to you too. And based on how often I would see electric smoke when I rodeoed a Titan it seems others felt the same. So perhaps they saw this and thought let's change how rodeo works so people use the options in that slot.
If there is no A.I. I blame it on the new servers and who knows maybe ps4, for not being able to handle that many calculations.
I was wondering that as well. If I recall Microsoft said they would open up their cloud for anyone, but maybe respawn or Sony said no?
this beta play was fun to play but I agree with all your comments. One other thing I found is the anti-titan weapons were not nearly as effective and the Titan weapons didn't feel as powerful, taking many hits on the AI or pilots to actually kill. I currently find the original TitanFall to be more enjoyable still.
I agree on attacking players with the Titans. I'm at best middling at Titanfall but always preferred the faster Titans; in the tech test I ended up having to use Scorch as I could at least kill pilots (mainly with the thermal bomb or whatever it was called that you ignited). Trying to kill anything human sized with the Ion's cannon was virtually beyond my aged skills!
They won't be able to fix these issues before launch unless they delay the game. This is why you do these tests 11 months before launch (Halo 5), not 2.
Titans felt very very underpowered and when I finally got one it just didn't feel as though I was going to do much good in it. Granted, I'm used to my Ogre/Triple Threat combo in the first game but one if the weapons used by Titans was sooooo slow to reload it was almost pointless! Felt good to play but hope they balance out more...glad you explained what the battery thing was, as I didn't have a clue!
Movement (including wall running) is slowed down and sluggish. The general response is sluggish. I feel like the characters in TF2 are at least 25-30 lbs heavier than in the original Titanfall. I guess the pilots all went on vacation and got fat between the first and second game. Also, the jump feels heavier and you begin to drop faster so stringing jumps together doesnt feel the same. Its worse. The weapons and hit detection are horrible and the servers tic rate must be off because hit enemies often dont get hurt. Map design does not allow for the same level of continuous wall running as the original is beloved for. It feels like CoD. Maybe Call of Titans. Everything now is based on sort of killstreaks/how many enemies you kill. You can no longer carry a primary, secondary, AND anti titan weapon at the same time. You have to decide between a sidearm or an ant titan weapon. The Titan timer is gone which sucks. Your Titan starts out with no over shield. Now, in TF2 you need one of your teammates to first rodeo an enemy titan, steal his batteries (so corny), then try to survive while bringing the battery to you, rodeo your titan, and then you'll finally have an over shield. How is it that these new Titans are supposed to be more advanced than the previous titans, yet their vortex shield is garbage and they have no over shield or particle wall from start? There is no particle shield for Titans and these new Titans are useless and slow (I want my Stryder back). The vortex shield rarely catches and returned enemy fire (possibly because most of the new Titan weapons are lasers or actual fire and not munitions/projectiles/bullets. The new Gravity Star is useless and only works IF the enemy sits perfectly still and lets you throw it directly on them. I've thrown it right next to them and it only made some glowing visual thing but didnt even pull the enemy up into the air. Its garbage. The grappling hook does not stick to every object, as developers claim it does. Also, it often seems to have a mind of its own, swinging you where you dont want it to take you. Also, now instead of being able to.shoot out a Titans core when you rodeo them, you simply steal their battery. Thats just dumb. Also, quite a number of times, in the same second that my titan prompted me to eject, it blew up. How's about a warning a little earlier and then give me time to hit the x button. Another problem is when enemies grapple toward titans. I've shot them as they were coming toward me, I've punched them also. But still, somehow they still attach to my Titan. This game is a huge disappointment. So much so that I've cancelled my preorder. Its a shame. But I guess it's true what they say: Lighting doesnt strike twice. one of the special things about OG Titanfall was the smart AI (thanks to MSFTs Azure servers). They didn't act like regular AI in other games. They actually reacted to you in different ways and could often be seen helping downed ai and conversing with one another. They had a real presence in OG Titanfall. But they are noticeably less in number, not as smart , and not have much of a personality at all in TF2. They're devoid of any personality. They're just empty shells now. And it takes away yet another key feature that made the original game so special. Perhaps Respawn decided that sonys servers wouldn't be able to handle the amount of smart AI that MSFTs servers could handle, they chose to dumb down all of the AI to keep the experience uniform across all platforms. While Id understand that reasoning (if that was the case), it would be a shame since it removes such a special feature that OG Titanfall gamers have grown fond of. Btw, I fired up the original last night and felt like I was home. However, after playing the tech test, I now felt so slow in a super fast paced game. My reaction time was off. Titanfall 2 got me used to slow gameplay. It took me a couple minutes to adjust back to the amazingly fast and frantic pace that is True Titanfall.
Response from developer. http://www.titanfall.com/en_us/news/tech-test-and-feedback/
Jez I agree on all points! Thank you. I hope the final product is better because I had so much fun with friends on Titanfall. Titanfall 2 so far just wasn't fun too me. I thought they would just add a campaign, add more variety of guns, customization, new maps, new titans on top of the already awesome gameplay. They really made a lot of changes. I will play this weekend and see how things are then.
Thank you for reading. Hope that things improve. :)
Get the best of Windows Central in in your inbox, every day!
Thank you for signing up to Windows Central. You will receive a verification email shortly.
There was a problem. Please refresh the page and try again.