Control Xbox One review: A solid game that fails to meet its potential

Control has a lot of awesome ideas, but it fails to truly capitalize on those foundations.

(Image: © 505 Games)

Developer Remedy Entertainment's Quantum Break is one of my all-time favorite third-person shooter titles, as it blended satisfying gunplay with unique supernatural powers and a great narrative that was as engaging as it was gripping. Therefore, when I saw that its new game, Control, was looking to improve upon the Remedy formula even further, I was ecstatic to get my hands on the title to see what the studio's creative minds had come up with next.

Unfortunately, after completing the game, I'm left feeling disappointed about Control. The game introduces several new ideas to the table, but it doesn't capitalize on all of them. In some ways, it's even a step back from what Remedy achieved with Quantum Break. Control is far from bad ⁠— in fact, it's solid ⁠— but it's also far from being amazing, too.

Become the Director

Control places you in the shoes of a woman named Jesse Faden, who has arrived on-site at the headquarters of the secretive FBC (Federal Bureau of Control), an organization dedicated to containing and controlling supernatural entities. With the previous Director killed by an invasive force colloquially known as "the Hiss," Jesse arrives to fill his shoes. And with the help of the FBC personnel, she gets to work cleansing the building of Hiss presence, preventing it from spreading to the outside world. The overall narrative of Control is best left as a mystery for you to uncover, so I won't spoil anything more than this brief synopsis and critique.

There's a ton of interesting lore and world-building to be found in Control, ranging from official documentation of Hiss enemy types to casual memos between employees. One of the best types of these collectibles are short video clips done with live-action film, depicted in-game as training videos. I love seeing Remedy continue to experiment with live-action footage in its games — it was done wonderfully in Quantum Break, and Remedy made it work well in Control, too.

Control's story has a great premise, but its characters leave a lot to be desired.

Unfortunately, the story starts to take a dip in quality when it comes to the actual characters themselves. While the plot premise and setting are excellent, they can't hide a bland cast of characters and an uninteresting script. While there are a few notable personalities, such as the chipper researcher Emily Pope or the creepy janitor, Ahti, none of the others really piqued my interest, including the protagonist herself, Jesse. They're not bad, but they aren't anything special, either. This is a big disappointment, considering Remedy's previous titles have all had superb characters.

Supernatural superpowers

The majority of Control's gameplay revolves around its combat, in which you use both your firearm and your supernatural powers in order to dispose of Hiss-infected hosts and entities. Both of these are versatile; your gun can be used in several different firing modes that range from pistol to missile launcher and everything between. You can use your powers to pick up objects and throw them at enemies, create a wall of rubble in front of you to use as a shield, and more. This gives you a huge amount of different ways to approach combat, which helps keep the fighting fresh throughout the game.

Just because you have a strong arsenal, though, doesn't mean that the Hiss aren't a challenge. From infected troopers wearing kevlar body armor to horribly mutated FBC agents that can fly, the Hiss' army is vast and diverse. Each enemy type will require you to change your combat approach. For example, there's one special type of soldier that has a powerful energy shield. Bullets are weak against them, but thrown objects penetrate it easily. Another foe you'll encounter is a support unit that floats near other enemies and constantly heals them, so you'll be forced to go after them first.

Outside of the combat, though, the gameplay is pretty uninteresting. Exploration and solving puzzles constitute the rest of what you'll be doing when you aren't battling the Hiss, but the former is marred by confusing level design while the latter is laughably simple. I frequently spent several minutes just trying to figure out how to navigate from A to B within the title's unnecessarily complex layout, and many of the puzzles boil down to throwing a battery cube into an empty slot to power something up. There were a couple of creative ones, but the vast majority were simplistic and unengaging to solve.

Presentation and polish

Control is a series of ups and downs, and that trend continues when it comes to the game's presentation and polish.

Let's start with the good: Control is a gorgeous game, and its attention to visual detail is stunning. The visual fidelity of everything, from the characters to the NPCs to the environment, is simply incredible. I wouldn't say it's the best looking game out on Xbox One right now, but it's pretty high up there. The title's environments are varied and diverse as well, with the cold, clinical feel of a federal research building and the damp, musty depths of the maintenance sector contrasting wonderfully with the blood-red and pitch-black aesthetic of Hiss-infested zones.

Control's visuals are stunning, but the music is disappointing and the game needs more polish.

Aside from the graphics, though, Control yet again leaves things to be desired. The musical score is forgettable and doesn't do much to support pivotal moments in gameplay or story, and the title also has quite a handful of performance issues. The worst one I encountered in my playthrough was with the map disappearing, partially or fully, in the user interface. Control's levels are already confusing enough; losing the ability to use the map just made things even more grating. The game also tended to stutter in areas with a lot going on, and rooms full of props hit my framerate. I'm playing on an Xbox One X and having these problems, so I imagine that it will be even worse for Xbox One and Xbox One S players, and those on a less capable PC.

Should you buy Control?

Ultimately, Control is a solid game that offers a really fun combat system to experience, a fascinating world full of interesting information to discover, and gorgeous visuals to glue your eyes to — even if many other aspects of its design are large disappointments. While I finished Control feeling let down after expecting Remedy Entertainment to outdo themselves, it's still a title that many players will enjoy.

If you're planning on getting the game thinking that it's going to be the next Quantum Break, I advise that you to wait for a sale, as Control is a step down from Remedy's previous title in terms of overall quality. However, if you don't mind the issues I brought up too much, you can get the game right now. You probably won't feel disappointed by it too badly.

Control comes out August 27, 2019 on Xbox One, PlayStation 4, and PC for $60.

Brendan Lowry is a Windows Central writer and Oakland University graduate with a burning passion for video games, of which he's been an avid fan since childhood. You'll find him doing reviews, editorials, and general coverage on everything Xbox and PC. Follow him on Twitter.

  • Got the game few days early.. Game looks very good with Ray-tracing etc. but I prefer Quantum break over control.
  • I'll definitely buy it since i am a huge QB fan but that ps4 exclusive content nonsense prevents me from buying it at full price . I'll wait .
  • Anything from Night Springs?! 👀
  • I'm looking forward to it, it's getting pretty decent reviews across the board on Metacritic, with only the PS4 version lagging slightly behind the other two systems. And from what I read in this review it has the same issues Quantum Break did so I can let it go.
  • Yeah had a mate play this early. He basically said, Alan Wake and Quantum Break this isn't. It's not as good as those 2 games. Sad to see Remedy lose their way so much. I feel like they are just trying to find new mechanics now. And losing sight of what they did good. Storytelling.
  • You know, I'm rather surprised at how my score varies from other outlets. I feel the same as your friend. But oddly enough it seems like most others think it's better than AW and QB. I suppose different strokes for different folks.
  • There is a small part of me who thinks because it's now on PS also it automatically gets higher marks.
  • Actually no, it's scoring lower on PS4 than the Xbox One Probably because it has a bit more competition in the SP narrative genre. I actually, so far, like it a little bit more than Quantum Break, but not as much as Max Payne (which started everything so that's probably more nostalgia) and Alan Wake, which just had a wonderful realised world. My main gripe with Quantum Break, other than the visuals, was that it moved a lot further from the bat**** crazy David Lynch vibes of Alan Wake. Control, so far, feels like it's moving back to that which is what made me fall in love with Remedy narratives in the first place.
  • No it's scoring less on PS4 because it's a technical mess. On base PS4 it drops to 10 fps. And averages around 18 fps on a regular basis in fights. On PS4 Pro, again it can drop to 14 fps. And sits around 20 fps most of the time. The Xbox One S version outperforms PS4 base. But is 720p vs 900p. Xbxo One X version maintains 30 fps the most. Has some dips into mid 20s. But nothing to worry about. Basically according to Digital Foundry. Absolutely do not buy this product on any PS4 currently. It's probably the worst performing framerate I've ever seen this Gen on PS4. It's beyond terrible.
  • Yeah, Xbox One X does run fairly well, but there is also some pretty significant slowdown, but it's very rare (happened twice to me where it's dropped to a slide show for a second, then back to fluid). So yeah, I imagine the PS4 versions would fare worse. That and the map bug, that's infuriating. I'm absolutely floored by the projector effects in the game though, it's the most interesting thing and I'm not sure if anything else has done it prior. I'm not going to stand up and say it isn't without its faults, I just feel that the faults of QB were slightly worse than the faults of Control. But I also think that my issues with Control could be fixed with a patch, although I'll probably have completed the game and traded it in before that happens.