Skip to main content

Mesh Wi-Fi pros and cons

Mesh Wi-Fi is something you're probably hearing more and more about, especially since some of the big players in home networking equipment are getting involved. Having a mesh system probably isn't quite what you're used to, and there are definite pros as well as cons to going this route.

Here we quickly break down some of the key points in each category.

What is mesh Wi-Fi?

This snippet from our guide on choosing the right home network for you sums it up well.

Mesh networks are a more advanced option and sport an interesting design that allows data to leap between relays to reach a specific destination. This skips a central hub or router calling all the shots. So instead of having a single point of access for all devices, a mesh network can consist of multiple relays that connect with one another and can quickly direct traffic between devices.

Nodes connect together in a mesh rather than a linear pattern. This means that all nodes can talk to all other nodes. With a router and Wi-Fi extender arrangement, each extender talks to the router but not any other extenders.

Mesh Wi-Fi pros

Better coverage

One of the main positives to a mesh Wi-Fi system is better coverage throughout your home. You're no longer relying on a router in one spot broadcasting signal throughout the entire building, but instead, a network of nodes all working together. Placing nodes throughout provides better overall coverage with less signal drop.

No single point of failure

There is no main access point in a mesh network. All nodes are alike, and while you'll still need the one connected to the broadband connection to keep working properly for internet access, the network will remain active regardless. And as they're all alike, if you encounter a problem with one node, it can easily be replaced by another.

A single network

When you're using a repeater in conjunction with a router, you end up with separate network connections, hopping potentially between different access points. Mesh networks maintain a single SSID and connection throughout, intelligently connecting you to the best node.

Modular

A mesh network can be as big or small as you wish. Because each node is just a single module in the overall network, you can always add or take them away as is necessary. There's minimal setup involved in adding a new node, too.

Mesh Wi-Fi cons

Price

Mesh Wi-Fi solutions right now are expensive. You'll probably be able to get a good router and repeater for less than a mesh system.

Scalability

Range from each node is less than you would get from a router or an extender, and as such scaling across a large house will require a number of nodes which then comes back partly to price. Coverage will only be better if you can provide enough nodes to suit your building.

Lacks advanced features

Designed to be extremely consumer-friendly, some of the current mesh systems are somewhat lacking in features that power users might want. These include things like changing the DHCP IP, adding custom DNS or even running both a 2.4GHz and 5GHz band network. They're designed to be simple.

Speed will still suffer at extremities

If you're buying a mesh system expecting it to maintain the same internet speeds across your whole home you'll be disappointed. Wireless signal degrades the further it gets from the point of origin. Even with mesh, the signal starts at one node, with the others having to then pick that up and amplify it as it rebroadcasts. The only way to get the best speeds throughout is to use a wired network.

Bottom line on mesh Wi-Fi

Mesh Wi-Fi is very good. Its biggest pluses are helping you get much better coverage throughout your entire home with a single SSID and the ability to intelligently switch between nodes as required.

But, it's not perfect and is also expensive. Many systems are designed to be very user-friendly, but we're still in the early days of consumer-grade products. Only you can decide whether they're right for you by weighing the good against the bad, and if you're happy to pay a premium.

More: Best mesh Wi-Fi systems

Richard Devine is an Editor at Windows Central. A former Project Manager and long-term tech addict, he joined Mobile Nations in 2011 and has been found on Android Central and iMore as well as Windows Central. Currently you'll find him covering all manner of PC hardware and gaming, and you can follow him on Twitter and Instagram.

5 Comments
  • There is two Cons that are not correct in a properly defined mesh system. First is that that range between nodes is shorter. This is false. A good mesh system can actually have the same or sometimes even better range than a traditional Wi-Fi. The other is speed. A good Wi-Fi mesh had dedicated back haul to ensure there is no loss of speed even at the extremities. In that case only distance from the node degrades speed but the same is true of regular Wi-Fi. Also, better mesh systems allow ethernet backhand to guarantee node to node performance. Two cons to add Often consumer grade Wi-Fi often isn't truly mesh and doesn't actually do proper seemed handoff between nodes or does so poorly. Even higher end consumer mesh systems sometimes will allow a client to hang onto a distant node while moving causing performance to suffer. Consumer grade mesh systems often don't include self healing either.
  • Love my Netgear Orbi, Price is the only con but I considered it worth it instead of using range extenders.
  • The Netgear Orbi system has great range and speed, but it is not actually a mesh system. It is a router + satellite (extender) system.
  • I've tried many router/repeater configurations (non-enterprise) and I have found them more than lacking.  I've been waiting to put in a mesh system but not really sure I need enterprise (guys at work are insisting on it).  I do need some of the "more advanced" configuration options, however, and that is why I haven't pulled the trigger. The initial focus on "ease of use" is beating out more fleshed out advanced customization. I still enjoy reading reviews, though. So, I appreciate the work involved whether its paid or not. :) I can at least say that I'll never knowingly buy a Google networking appliance. Or anything, if I can avoid it.  Their primary business is advertising.  To that end, I will probably trust their service less than any random other by default.
  • I'm currently using the Linkysys Velop system, which I believe is one of the few true mesh systems for consumers. The range for each individual node is not nearly as good as a single, strong router, but it works well as a mesh network. It's easy to use, with the downside being that advanced functionality is harder to do because it can only be controlled via a phone app. I believe it is also self-healing, if self-healing means that one node will help the other get back online if the other one goes down.