Last year, I wrote about switching from a Surface Book to a Razer Blade 14, citing the Blade's superior CPU and GPU as the reasons why. Now that the Surface Book 2 is here, I couldn't resist the urge to switch back.
I really enjoy the Razer Blade 14. It's a beastly device, without sacrificing style and size. Not only can it run games like a dream, it powers through all other tasks with ease, including video editing, heavy duty Photoshop, and even Mixed Reality and VR. Considering the internal spec difference between the Blade and the Surface Book 2 are negligible, why did I feel the need to drop over a thousand extra euros to switch back to Surface?
The reasons are numerous and potentially nuanced, but it boils down to one thing: the Surface Book 2 is the perfect device for me. And my experiences might help you decide which device is best for you.
Surface Book 2 15-inch vs. Razer Blade 14 (2017): Tech specs
|Category||Surface Book 2 15-inch||Razer Blade 14 (2017)|
|Display||15-inch PixelSense Display|
3:2 aspect ratio
|14-inch IGZO Screen|
16:9 aspect ratio
|Resolution||3840 x 2160 (4K horizontal, Touch, Inking)||1920 x 1080 (HD), Non-touch|
3200 x 1800 (QHD+), Touch
3840 x 2160 (4K), Touch
|OS||Windows 10||Windows 10|
|CPU||Core i5-7300U (3.2GHz)|
Core i7-8650U (4.2GHz)
|Core i7-7700HQ 2.8GHz / 3.8GHz (Base / Turbo)|
|Storage||256GB, 512GB, or 1TB PCIe NVMe SSD||256GB, 512GB, or 1TB PCIe NVMe SSD|
|Graphics||Intel HD Graphics 620|
GTX 1060 (6GB)
|Intel HD Graphics 620|
GTX 1060 (6GB)
|Ports||Two USB Type-A 3.1 (Gen1)|
USB Type-C with video, power in/out and USB 3.1 (Gen1) data
Headphone and microphone
Full-size SDXC card reader (UHS-II)
|One Thunderbolt 3 (USB-C)|
One HDMI 2.0a
12/13-inch: Two USB 3.0 ports (SuperSpeed)
14-inch: Three USB 3.0 port (SuperSpeed)
Razer Chroma Lighting (Black Models)
|Weight||4.20 lbs (1.9 kg)||4.3lbs (1.95kg)|
|Dimensions||13.5 in (343 mm) x 9.87 in (251 mm) x 0.57 in to 0.90 in (15mm to 23 mm)||0.70 in (17.9 mm) x 13.6 in (345 mm) x 9.3 in (235 mm)|
|Price||Starts at $2,499 (opens in new tab)||Starts at $1,800 (opens in new tab)|
The Razer Blade experience
The Blade and the Book are fundamentally different devices, but they can be used for similar tasks. The Blade's quad-core processing and GTX 1060 GPU makes a breeze of intensive gaming, video editing, and Windows Mixed Reality, and produce a smooth Windows 10 experience across the board. Performance-wise, there's nothing to complain about with the Razer Blade, which packs a magical amount of power into a svelte, 4.3-pound package.
I was using the Blade's 1080p non-touch offering, and while this display is nowhere as impressive as the Surface Book 2's, it more than gets the job done. I was amazed at how much I actually missed the touch capabilities on Windows 10, and if you feel the same, know that Razer offers touch variants of this device. But if you want digital inking, you'll have to get an external drawing tablet.
Perhaps the biggest annoyance I experienced personally with the Blade was the noise. Even lighter tasks like Skype calls would engage the fans underneath, which are incredibly noisy. If you fire up Windows Mixed Reality or even a modest game, the Razer Blade will sound as though it's about to blast off into orbit. It got to a point where I was trying to work around the noise, looking into cooling pad solutions or deliberately lowering the frames per second (FPS) or resolution in games to make it run a little more quietly.
Some other minor gripes with the Blade include the non-Precision touchpad, which while not terrible is a far cry from Microsoft's Surface line, although you can install Microsoft's Precision drivers to improve the situation.
There are now some gunmetal variants, but most Blades are matte black, making them prone to visible smudges and dust. You'll potentially be cleaning it a lot, and it's made all the more annoying by the fact the speaker grills face upwards next to the keyboard.
For the most part though, the Blade is a beautiful and ultimately reliable device. I've never had a single crash or hang through several months of daily use. If you're willing to put up with the noise, it'll crush most modern games with ease, and it makes a joy of more intensive tasks like VR and video editing. This is the ultimate laptop for those who need something that travels with them, while not sacrificing the power, provided you don't want inking.
Surface Book 2 is a Swiss Army Knife
The Surface Book 2 is an gorgeous slab of engineering like no other. It's truly stunning how Microsoft was able to squeeze so much power into a relatively thin device. The CPU and other internals are packed into the display, while the GPU and batteries reside in the base, which comes with that unique fulcrum hinge.
The internals are relatively similar between the Blade and the Book 2. Quad-core processing joins a 6GB GTX 1060 for high-end gaming and other tasks, and crucially for me, the Surface Book 2 doesn't sound like a jet engine when under heavy load. That's not to say it doesn't get noisy at times, but you really have to push it.
The Surface Book 2 has a weaker CPU than the Blade, and it shows. The Blade produces a smoother OS experience, both in terms of animations and speed. Multi-tasking is noticeably better on the Blade, too. As I type this, I have a few programs open, and adding Google Hangouts into the mix (which is notoriously resource-heavy), the Surface Book 2 is having a slightly harder time than my Blade would have had.
When you're not multi-tasking, the difference is harder to notice. Gaming performance generally feels near-identical, and the Surface Book 2's display really makes some games shine, particularly space games, making use of the Book 2's deep blacks. The Book 2 can suffer from battery drain in certain situations, when you're pushing it really hard, but it's unlikely you'll encounter this issue if you're using the Book 2's official charger.
The Book 2 should generally outperform the Blade on battery life, although you're not going to get more than an hour or two while running an intensive game on either. For general use, though, I get around five to six hours on the Blade, and around eight to 10 on the Book 2, which is impressive.
Most impressive of all is just how versatile the Surface Book 2 is. It's a creative studio in a single package, offering robust digital inking, high-level processing power, and a stunning display. It's also several hundred dollars more expensive than the Blade.
Which should you buy?
The Blade and Book 2 might seem similar when you're the looking at the internals, but ultimately, the choice boils down to what you intend to use them for. Both devices are beautiful, well-designed, robust, and powerful, packing serious processing into a petite package.
Unless you intend to use digital ink, flipping the screen and laying it flat for artsy pursuits, it's almost impossible to recommend the Book 2 at that price point. There are simply cheaper options out there, which are often more powerful to boot. What you will get if you choose Surface over Razer are refinements: slimmer bezels, better cameras, a better trackpad, an SD-card slot, and a better display. But whether all of that is worth the extra cash is something only you can decide.
The Blade provides a slightly smoother OS and multi-tasking experience, at the cost of fan noise. While the Book 2 provides better battery life, you won't experience any sort of throttling while using the Blade, and you also have the option of Thunderbolt 3 peripherals, such as an external GPU.
I think for pure gamers, the Blade should certainly be considered first, but the Surface Book 2 is a jack of all trades across the board for creatives, prosumers, and gamers, and truly represents Windows at its best and most versatile.
Jez Corden is the Managing Editor for Windows Central, focusing primarily on all things Xbox and gaming. Jez is known for breaking exclusive news and analysis as relates to the Microsoft ecosystem while being powered by caffeine. Follow on Twitter @JezCorden and listen to his Xbox Two podcast, all about, you guessed it, Xbox!
The Surface Book exists because no other device can do what it does. It really is unique and if your workflow requires what it can give (like for myself) then it is absolutely worth it. I do digital inking, note taking, and photo editing with it. I am also earning a Master's Degree. But my day job is as a software developer (independent) and this is the only device that I can throw into a bag that can do it all. Most normal people will do better with another device for much cheaper!
Exactly. I think you'll just know it if you are one of the folks who really need the Surface Book. If you're questioning it, thinking too hard about it, and are second guessing yourself constantly, you're better off getting a cheaper alternative like an Dell XPS 15 or a Razerblade 14.
Recommendation for Google Hangouts, btw? Use the aoo "Messenger for Google Hangouts PRO" in the App Store. It will change your life forever. :) * and your dependence on Google Chrome
Thanks for the tip!
The specs you listed for the 15" surface book are wrong. It only comes with the 8th Gen i7 and 16gb of ram.
Thanks! Great article. Loving my Sb2 15"!
You made 1 minor mistake. The Blade 14 has Intel Graphics 630 not 620. I know minimal difference but still a difference. I'd probably go with the Blade just because the Thunderbolt port. If Microsoft would just add the freaking TB3 I'd go for the Surface.
Looking at the capabilities of the 8560U processor, I don't think they could have included a Thunderbolt 3 port (at least not one with the necessary 4 PCI lanes). What the Surface team should do instead (and I wish Windows Central would discuss publicly to help spread the idea far enough to get the Surface team interested) is create a sort of base station that includes either a TB3 port or (even better) a box with a PCI slot attached. What I mean is, they should make an accessory that essentially turns the Surface Book's "clipboard" into a mini Surface Studio, complete with a user-upgradable options. I'd like to see a base station with plenty of USB ports, an SD card reader, an internal HDD slot (but this is very unlikely since it could confuse users' storage options), and a PCI slot for a full-size GPU. This would allow users an opportunity to keep a full-scale desktop environment set up, and all they have to do is pop the clipboard off and plug it into the dock. Then, the desktop comes to life and takes advantage of the peripherals and GPU attached to the base station.
I've talked about that idea on the podcast and some of our videos before. I'll just say there are proposals at Microsoft...
Thank you for signing up to Windows Central. You will receive a verification email shortly.
There was a problem. Please refresh the page and try again.