Windows Mail is the free app bundled with the OS that is ideal for those who use email sparingly, but Outlook is the solution for anyone who's serious about electronic messaging.

A fresh install of Windows 10 offers a number of software solutions, including one for email and calendar. Windows Mail (better known as Mail and Calendar) is one-half of an email account and calendar offering — the other being Calendar — and is a lightweight app designed to handle multiple accounts and fairly moderate email use. But is it worth switching to Outlook, and who is suite designed for?

For Anyone

Windows Mail

To those who have already used a version of Outlook in the past, the Windows Mail app will come across as a lightweight variant with some features omitted from the experience. The main difference between Outlook and the Mail app is the target audience. The bundled app with Windows is meant to cater to consumers and those who check their emails on a daily basis. Outlook on-the-other-hand is for business and professionals who rely on email.

But just because the Windows Mail app is more basic than Outlook, it doesn't necessarily mean that it's a worse experience. The app itself is a solid client for email, and the accompanying calendar app will handle events, subscriptions to cloud-based calendars just fine. A neat feature of the Mail and Calendar apps is the design language, which fits in comfortably with Windows 10.

Various accounts can be added to Windows Mail, including Outlook.com, Exchange (Office 365), Gmail, Yahoo! Mail, iCloud, as well as usual POP and IMAP accounts. Using Microsoft's hosted email services like Outlook.com will ensure everything is configured and synchronized without much effort. Simply enter your account credentials, and the app will handle everything else. Other service providers may require additional steps.

Windows Mail

Thanks to its free, basic feature set, the Windows Mail app has been designed and developed to take full advantage of touch support on tablets and laptops. It's possible to utilize the on-screen keyboard and use the app to filter through messages and reply to contacts.

One issue I continue to experience, as well as other Mail app users, is the problem with mail synchronization. Attempting to synchronize all accounts can result in errors, which is not only irritating but requires troubleshooting. Contact integration from connected profiles isn't perfect either, but again this is a more streamlined app and it's possible to hit up contacts when creating (or replying to) emails.

Windows Mail

I also dislike the fact you need to switch between apps for mail and calendar appointments. But it is free, so there's that huge plus.

Mail and Calendar for Windows 10 FAQ

Pros:

  • Great touch support
  • Easy to use
  • Free, bundled with Windows 10

Cons:

  • Basic
  • Issues with mail sync
  • Separate apps for mail and calendar

For Professionals

Outlook

Outlook is Microsoft's premium email client and is regarded as one of the best in the business. There's a good reason for this as the suite has been around for many years as part of Microsoft Office. The company has had mass amounts of time to invest in developing improvements to take the experience to the next level and increase productivity. While the Windows Mail app may just do the job for daily or weekly email checking, Outlook is for those who rely on email.

As well as the powerful email client, Microsoft has packed in calendar, contacts and task support. Simply switch between tabs and everything is loaded up. Office integration is also present, as one would expect from a more connected suite of productivity tools. Then there's the Ribbon system that hides away the countless buttons and features that do pretty much everything one would require.

Outlook

Take a look at some of the feature discrepancies to see if there's anything you require that cannot be done in the Windows Mail app:

Feature Outlook Windows Mail
View/Send mail from Shared Mailboxes Yes No
Access to Public Folders Yes No
Categorize messages Yes No
Ignore conversation Yes No
Clean up thread Yes No
Apps for Office Yes No
Unsubscribe to mass emails Yes No
MailTips Yes No
Follow Up Flag (creating email) Yes No
Send email as plain text Yes No
Create Inbox rules Yes No
Local Email storage Yes No
Contacts list Yes No
Highlight terms in search results Yes No
Open colleagues' calendars Yes No

More information and comparison between the two apps can be found on Microsoft's website.

There are downsides to Microsoft's more advanced email program. The first being the plethora of features that may never be used. Do you really need to categorize messages? That and the new Ribbon UI system that Microsoft has implemented into the new Office suite isn't to everyone's liking. It can also feel rather bloated when tasked to handle thousands upon thousands of emails from multiple accounts, but that's a case of not effectively managing clutter.

And don't get me started on some of the account setup issues. I've experienced the following a few times before it starts magically working for some reason. Outlook just can't seem to connect and log in when initially setting up some accounts that require manual labor, asking you to re-enter credentials a few times before finally accepting defeat and connecting everything up.

Outlook

That said, it makes sense for Microsoft to offer more features in the Outlook suite to entice businesses and consumers to upgrade and pay the Office subscription, but if you don't need many of the more advanced features the Mail app will do just fine.

Pros:

  • Superb feature set
  • Handles mail, calendar, contacts
  • Great filter, search and flagging
  • Integrates with other MS Office products

Cons:

  • Requires Office 365 subscription
  • More complicated
  • Setting up accounts can be a pain
  • Not designed for touch

What say you?

Do you prefer the simplicity of Windows Mail (and Calendar) or are you a fan of the more feature-rich Outlook suite? Sound off in the comments!