Skip to main content

Windows 'phone' isn't dead Part II: Nurturing the ecosystem

During that vulnerable stage, the child is prone to many dangers. Caring parents, therefore, provide a host of necessary supports to nurture the child prenatally to ensure his/her healthy development, survival, and long-term health.

Since Windows Phone 7's introduction in 2010, Microsoft's renewed smartphone agenda has been in full swing. Despite several starts and restarts along the way, however, Microsoft's mobile phone efforts are once again in a state of gestation. This position is a result of Microsoft's retrenching from the general smartphone market last year.

Microsoft HQ

Microsoft HQ (Image credit: Windows Central)

During this retrenching phase, the company is focused on fans, enterprise and value markets and is determined to release only two phones a year for each segment with little marketing and limited distribution. During this stage of "re-development," the company must nurture its evolving mobile OS, developing OEM partnerships and growing app ecosystem to ensure the vitality and long-term success of its gestating mobile strategy.

In part one of this series we took a birds-eye view of Microsoft's strategy during this state of "gestation." In this piece, we will look more closely at specific components of Microsoft's ecosystem that the company is or should be nurturing while retrenched.

Bed rest

As Apple, Samsung, LG and a host of other smartphone manufacturers aggressively pursue the most vibrant "personal computing" space, Microsoft is no longer directly chasing the consumer smartphone market. The firm's mobile platform doesn't have the audience, mature OS, competitive app ecosystem, nor a first-party device that inspires and excites consumers and developers to adopt the platform.

Lumia 950 and Surface

Lumia 950 and Surface (Image credit: Windows Central)

To that last point many fans have looked toward Q4 of this year, approximately nine months from now, envisioning the expected Surface Phone. Inspired by what Microsoft's Panos Panay and his team have delivered by way of the Surface and Surface Book there are high hopes for what a potential Surface Phone will bring to the table.

Exquisite hardware design and seamless hardware and software synergy are minimum expectations. Some intriguing hardware capabilities (that surprises as the Surface Books detachable display did) such as a keyboard or some form of docking station akin to the inspiring HP's Elite X3's mobile extender, that expands the devices capabilities and utilizes Continuum are also dancing at the fringes of our imaginations.

However, these things alone won't ensure the health and vitality of Microsoft's struggling mobile platform. Thus, as a woman experiencing a difficult pregnancy is restricted from normal activity, Microsoft has put its smartphone efforts on bed rest as it nurtures the Universal Windows ecosystem to ensure the health and vitality of its mobile strategy. Satya Nadella (opens in new tab) framed it this way:

"I am committed to our first-party devices including phones. However, we need to focus our phone efforts in the near term while driving reinvention. We are moving from a strategy to grow a standalone phone business to a strategy to grow and create a vibrant Windows ecosystem that includes our first-party device family…In the near term, we will run a more effective phone portfolio…We plan to narrow our focus to three customer segments…"

During this year and into 2017, I surmise Microsoft's efforts will and should be focused on elements of the Windows ecosystem that will enhance Windows phone's ability to not only survive but thrive in the market. It's critical that Windows 10 Mobile, the app bridges, and OEM partnerships receive diligent and unwavering focus during this year if the Surface Phone (if it manifests) and all other Windows phones are to have a positive long-term prognosis.

Regular check-ups

The vitality of Windows 10 Mobile is critical to the success of the Universal Windows Platform. Sadly, the launch of the 950/XL with software that still feels "under development" tempered the reception of these two high-end devices as well as the platform. Their launch, though limited in distribution, could have been a beaming representation of Windows 10 Mobile, as 2-in-1s have been for Windows 10 on the desktop, rather than the muted advent it was. Many Windows fans expressed then and continued to voice their discontent with the state of Windows 10 Mobile.

I concede that Windows enthusiasts are sometimes overzealous but as eager users of early builds of the platform, their respectful feedback using proper channels is critical. Thus, the relationship with users must continue to be nurtured during Microsoft's retrenching phase. Fan's regular access to early OS builds helps both Redmond and users remain focused, excited and in tune with what is important for the platform.

When my wife was pregnant with our daughter seeing the ultrasound images and hearing our daughter's heartbeat assured us that everything was ok, gave us a peek at her current stage of development and reignited our excitement for the future.

Regular Window 10 Mobile build releases provides a comparable experience for enthusiasts. Not only is the early public availability of the OS a means for Microsoft to garner feedback, but it also communicates to fans that the platform is still alive and kicking. With each build release fans essentially hear a "heartbeat," see platform development and are assured that the platform is ok and developing toward maturity following Microsoft's vision. This is particularly reassuring when the platform and its fans are enduring a deluge of negative sensationalist "news".

Additionally, OS updates often refresh the OS with new features that excite users and gives them new talking points. This experience, of course, encourages engagement with the platform, with Microsoft reps on social media and with one another. Therefore, regular updates for this passionate group who evangelize the platform is a critical component of the ecosystem.

A platform that has excited users receives consistent updates and has invested OEM partners is not dead.

Finally, Windows 10 Mobile updates keep the platform in the news cycle. Blogs that serve tens of millions of monthly visitors regularly post about the updates that are released. For those who claim that Windows Phone is dead, I contend that a platform that has excited users receives consistent upgrades and has invested OEM partners didn't die.

Partner Up? Why now?

Several weeks ago IDC released a report which indicated that Apple sold more of its flagship tablet, the iPad Pro, in its debut quarter than Microsoft sold Surfaces. Microsoft is likely not concerned, however, since that single data point fails to reveal the larger picture. As I shared with colleagues and hosts of Windows Central's OneCast, Jez Corden and Matt Brown on episode 5 of the show, Microsoft selling less hardware than Apple is not an area of concern. Why? Hardware isn't Microsoft's thing.

Consider this: Forty years ago when Microsoft founders Bill Gates and Paul Allen purposed to put a PC in every home and on every desk, they did not pursue this goal and achieve over 90% market saturation as a PC manufacturer. They achieved it through partnerships. They inspired the market with a vision of personal computing that PC manufactures ultimately embraced as Nadella asserts here:

"When I joined the company in '92, it was about the PC in every home and on every desk. Guess what: We achieved that. And a company has to outlast any given technology paradigm and any ambitious goal."

Forty years later they're doing the same with the Surface-inspired category of 2-in-1's. Microsoft's Panos Panay confirms how the Surface (and Windows 10) have influenced partners to embrace the optimal form factor for Windows 10:

"…one of the opportunities was to hopefully inspire others to think about the new categories and the devices we're creating… We're seeing this category beginning to take off a little bit right now. That's a good thing. I think Surface is one of the main drivers of that."

Microsoft has aligned its mobile "phone" strategy with this core strength and is trusting partnerships to push Windows 10 Mobile market penetration. The question, however, is why would OEMs support Microsoft's mobile initiative now when they've passed in the past?

A Different world

As I shared in Microsoft is Committed to Windows Phone, presenters Panos Panay and Brian Roper spent 21.8% of the entire October 6th, 2015 Windows 10 Devices event passionately presenting the high-end Lumias 950/XL. They concluded the phone segment with a meager 1 minute and 8 second nod to the low-end Lumia 550. This, in my estimation, was a public acknowledgment and appeal to the industry that the low-end space, which dominates Windows Phone representation in the market, and is ruled by Microsoft's Lumias, is now open to partners. Microsoft's cessation of the low-end push is the first reason partners may now embrace the platform.

Microsoft is committed to Windows Phone

The second reason is the value Microsoft's Universal Windows Platform brings to a Windows "phone". Combined with previous changes to Redmond's mobile strategy such as making the mobile OS free for devices under 8-inches and lowering hardware requirements so that OEMs can repurpose Android hardware (i.e. HTC M8), the UWP may convince Android OEMs to adopt Microsoft's platform.

The UWP uniquely allows OEMs to build a single device that fulfills the functions of a phone, tablet and PC as I shared in Highs and Lows Part VI – Noteworthy. Additionally, OEMs can market the synergy the UWP brings to a family of devices (i.e. phone, tablet and/or 2-in-1) in a way they cannot do with Android nor could they do with pre-Windows 10-based hardware.

HP, for example, has introduced an entire ecosystem around the HP Elite X3 and is presenting it as a platform for partners. This positioning is representative of Microsoft's strategy to be a "platform" for platforms.

Microsoft's aggressive push to rule personal computing Part II: Cross-platform clouds and alternate realities

Blurring the lines

Microsoft's nurturing of OEM partnerships during this gestating stage allows for a flow of new and innovative devices into the ecosystem. We will likely see a growing number of Microsoft's PC partners embracing the firms vision of personal computing which positions a Continuum enabled Windows "phone" as a transient all-in-one device.

Furthermore, I expect to see more Windows 10 Mobile tablets like Alcatal's 8" Pixie 3 LTE-enabled tablet which can technically be used to make phone calls.

Microsoft's mobile offensive is about changing the game

This device, consistent with Microsoft's personal computing ideology, straddles the line between "phone" and tablet. Moreover, when one considers the positioning of small Windows 10 Mobile tablets in conjunction with Microsoft's cellular app, which will allow users in select markets to purchase cellular data, the potential of Microsoft's "ambiguous" devices and platform becomes clearer. Combined with Skype for voice/video calls Microsoft's building of an ecosystem, not just devices, that blur the lines between phones and tablets begins to coalesce.

Microsoft's building of an ecosystem, not just devices, that blur the lines between phones and tablets begins to coalesce.

Additionally, though Microsoft, as an "OEM", has withdrawn from the consumer space until at least 2017, their partners are under no such constraints. As manufacturers such as Alcatel with its Windows 10 Mobile OneTouch Fierce XL on T-Mobile, enter the market it is possible that consumers will begin to take notice of Microsoft's mobile alternative that fits seamlessly with the Windows 10 ecosystem which a growing number of them will be using. Consider, Windows 10 has been installed on over 200 million devices since July 29th, 2015.

Microsoft's aggressive push to rule personal computing: Windows 10

Will the presence of these Windows 10 Mobile phones drive consumers to the platform? Unlikely. But as the synergies between Windows 10 Mobile, Windows 10 desktop and the broader Windows ecosystem continue to evolve, the visibility of consumer facing devices outside of the enterprise space will have increasing importance.

The visibility of consumer facing devices outside of the enterprise space will have increasing importance.

Finally, though a direct pursuit of consumers before the app bridges yield more popular apps is a risky proposition there is an interesting avenue that PC OEMs may find fruitful. The promotion of a Windows 10 Mobile "phone" as a member of a family of devices, with an HP Elite X3-type docking station geared toward students, may find a niche among that group.

A single device that serves as both laptop and phone could cost less than a cell phone and laptop separately. Cool points with young people is where Microsoft needs to score in the consumer space.

The practicality of this solution is hard to dismiss. The ever present chicken-before-the-egg app dilemma does, however, present the negative social ramifications of a student committing to a platform void of the most popular and fad apps iOS and Android have. Propelled by the propositions utility, however, that barrier may not be as profound as it is when in the general population not framed as an education tool.

Bridge to success

The final and most critical area Microsoft must nurture during this gestation stage is the app bridges. When these bridges were introduced they generated a lot of optimism due to the prospects they offered. Islandwood (iOS), Centennial (Win32), Westminster (Web apps) and the recently canceled Astoria (Andriod) brought the promise of providing developers with the tools to easily bring their apps from other platforms to Windows 10. Naturally, with the app gap being the most persistent thorn in Microsoft's side, these tools have been perceived as a major factor in helping Windows phone succeed.

We will take an in depth look at this area in future parts of this series. But suffice it to say, without the popular apps that people love, Nadella's goal that people will move from needing Windows to loving Windows, will likely not happen for a significant number of users in relation to Windows Mobile phones. I contend then that if Microsoft is serious about users coming to love Windows, their push for developing and winning developers to the app bridges, despite positive prospects in the enterprise must be, and with the purchase of Xamarin, looks to be a priority to nurture.

Wrap Up

While Windows phone is in this retrenched state, it's critical that Microsoft nurtures the environment that breathes life into the platform. Critical updates to an OS that many contend launched prematurely, engagement with enthusiasts, aggressive support of OEM partners and an approach to the app bridges that pulls out all the stops are critical to the gestating Windows phones' survival and long-term health.

MWC has revealed refreshed partnerships and the Xamarin purchase reignites hope for the app ecosystem. Folks stay tuned to the rest of this series. Windows phone is not dead.

Part I: Windows 'phone' isn't dead: Keeping the vision in view

Jason L Ward is a columnist at Windows Central. He provides unique big picture analysis of the complex world of Microsoft. Jason takes the small clues and gives you an insightful big picture perspective through storytelling that you won't find *anywhere* else. Seriously, this dude thinks outside the box. Follow him on Twitter at @JLTechWord. He's doing the "write" thing!

  • Thanks again for reading folks!!! Windows is alive and Microsoft definitely has a plan. So what are your thoughts?
  • In the end though it is all about the apps. Unless iPhone quality apps get to the platform I don't think it matters if the hardware or OS are comparable. The nicest platform in the world is useless without apps...
  • I'm agree
  • Well iPhone quality doesn't necessarily mean high quality
  • iOS apps mostly have better quality.
  • I find it truly disingenuous to say - or even suggest - that iPhones and iOS aren't a formible force in mobile. The iPhone has thrived due to the vast selection of high quality apps and is the first choice for most mobile developers followed by Android. If there's one overriding issue with the Lumia it is the painfully small selection of high quality apps available.  Currently running on my iPhone 6: Starbucks Google Maps NYTimes Now Reuters RFI Chrome BBC Weather Monocle 24 Google Photos Reuters TV Instagram (latest version) CBC Radio AFP Mobile Google+ Tumblr Politico OpenTable NewsON AmazonVideo Chromecast Spyglass Bing B&H Photo Hotel Tonight Chase Yik Yak etc. etc. etc.
  • Not to mention all these fluff pieces are predicated on the competition just sitting on their hands and not doing anything to counter anything Microsoft does. Delusional as always.
  • @Theefman please take the opportunity if able to reread the piece.
    The entire article is based on what MS is doing for it's ecosystem while retrenched while it's rivals are aggressively pursuing the market. Your assertion that the points are "fluff" ignoring that reality reflects that you somehow missed this entire paragraph under subtitle Bed Rest:
    Bed rest "As Apple, Samsung, LG and a host of other smartphone manufacturers aggressively pursue the most vibrant "personal computing" space, Microsoft is no longer directly chasing the consumer smartphone market. The firm's mobile platform doesn't have the audience, mature OS, competitive app ecosystem, nor a first-party device that inspires and excites consumers and developers to adopt the platform." Now within that context as Samsung, Apple and everyone else develops, markets and sales devices everything I put forth on this piece is the nurturing of the ecosystem that MS is or should be doing to ensure WPs success. While the competition is "not sitting or their hands and definitely do quite a bit MS, as I shared in this piece MUST nurture various components of it's ecosystem and:
    1. Continue rolling out regular updates to insiders.
    2. Continue engagingn enthusiasts
    3. Continue nurturing OEM partnerships
    4. Continue pursuing aggressively the prospects promised by the app bridges and the Xamarin purchase. Again these things are actually proposed within the context of the competition doing what they do :-)
    Jason L Ward @JLTechWord
  • Theefman doesn't care about contents. Every article here just presents him(?) with a change to attack MS and/or author, no matter what it's about Posted from WC 920, 1520, 920, 635, 640 950XL
  • They near on are now, both ios and android are only getting little updates its getting stale, look at marshmallow its hardly a feature packed OS but the Google fan boys jumps on the few new stuff like its gonna change the mobile world. Microsoft are on great path they just need to see this all the way
  • What are the features that the competition has that Android M is missing? I cannot think of a single thing. Not dissing Windows, I want it to succeed, but Android M is not feature defficient in any way excluding direct updates for non-Nexus devices. I have a Nexus 6P and I am not missing out on any feature or security update. That said, I will pre-order a Surface Phone if it becomes a reality.
  • I used Android for a long time but started to feel unless you have a nexus your always waiting for updates, and also when you do get the update half of the stuff is missing by the maker and by the time you get it nexus has sometimes had 2 in that time. Had the lg g4 and moto x last year and just felt lacking after a while
  • Moto X gets updated almost as quickly as Nexus. Either way, the answer is easy, just get the Nexus. The 6p makes no compromises and updates even rival Apple. Posted via the Windows Central App for Android
  • Calling this a fluff piece does a real disservice to the author.
  • It is a fluff piece. Windows phone is dead. Microsoft can keep it on life support, but it is no longer functioning. Posted via the Windows Central App for Android
  • There's no such thing as "iPhone Quality" (this isn't a slant against the iPhone).
  • Agree....but if u notice ...some years ago when MS introduced win8 ...there wer really no such grt apps and if was then only for some limited 1Gb phones. But that time Nokia managed to keep the market up with their unique style and innovative apps like creative camera even android and ios fans felt jealous for such apps. And i can remember lumia 520 was most popular by that time. But Nokia managed it with their superb and stupendous engineering behind phone shape color and feel. So MS really needs to ensure quality and unique apps 1st exclusively for windows phone. And style must to catch gen next. Posted from Windows Central for Windows 10
  • When you compare iPhone with the entire Windows ecosystem, it's the former that lacks meaningful apps going forward.  To see this, just look at the laughable comparison between Surface Pro (a full-blown powerful computer miniaturised) and iPad Pro (a dinky little phone with a big screen).  As phones become as powerful as laptops most people are not going to be content with tiny little "applets" and will want the full feature functionality of powerful "applications".  Of course, this will always be difficult to pull off unless and until Intel produces a chip with low power consumption characteristics - hopefully the basis of and differentiating factor for Surface Phone.
  • I keep hearing about accessing Legacy apps on Phones... Those x86 apps are not built for the phone, they are for desktop. Consumers don't want old apps, they want new exciting apps on their smartphone. Even MS is trying to do the same with UWP apps on Win10.
  • My thoughts are plain and clear: To support wp until the very end.
  • Windows 10 mobile to be successful in terms of what all wp users is capture majority of mobile market which isn't possible bcoz of android. Sure Microsoft uwp strategy is a long run stratergy what will convince majority of them. Windows 10 mobile still has metro still UI though there are adaptive features like hamburger menu. But its the UI that got ppl not to go for Windows phone. Android was simple with dead icons and easy to use. Microsoft did something innovative that tech savvy users liked but bco of avg consumer windows 8 and phone failed and also failed to convince OEMs. UWP would definitely benefit windows 10 mobile but to what extent I certainly don't but it will for sure.
  • if you dont like the simply ui of android remember that you can change your launcher and lock screen like every second
  • Great read as always. MS will take the "mobile" scene in their time giving us a new brilliant device-type-thingy
  • microsofts problem is reinvention. we as consumers are forced to change with them "or else". they did poorly with win 8 but perfected it with 8.1. the developers they have does not get to catch up. so why not stay with android or apple who do not force change in the same way..
  • Another excellent read. Love the point of regular updates proving W10M not dead. Can we all just agree to call the HP Mobility Extender a lapdock? Phablet and lapdock. Much easier to say and understand.
  • When I think of the term "lapdock" I can't help but to envision a laptop body, but with a recess where the track pad would ordinarily be... This being where you'd physically dock the phone. A bit impractical for taking calls I grant you, but then if you built a microphone and earpiece into opposing ends of a wirelessly connected stylus, you could use that to take calls perhaps. My mind is running away with me now! Lol :)
  • I agree
  • Great article, can understand so much with what you was saying about going from needing windows 10 to loving it
  • Let's see, three resets, a wasted $7.8B that destoyed a perfectly great phone device maker, after over a year a mobile OS still in development that they can't work the bugs out of and lousy and uninspiring hardware since they destroyed Nokia. You're right it's not dead should be killed off!!
  • yeah it takes more than a year to develop an OS, and wasn't the 950 designed by Nokia? They weren't really doing anyhting for the platform themselves.
  • The fact of the matter is that if Microsoft didn't keep scrapping the OS and starting over again they wouldn't have only "one year to perfect an OS". In fact, they would have had five.
  • WP 2010 - 2016 3 major version changes +3 minor versions
    ​IOS 2008 - 2016 9 Major versions.
    Andriod 2010(Cupcake) - 2016 6 Major versions 18 minor versions The biggest reason for "Scrapping" was to move from Windows CE to Windows NT kernal based OS.  The first step in Unifying the Windows Eco system.  Imagine doing that with 20-50% market share.