PSA: Alleged 'Lumia Emerald' sightings are most likely a hoax
Although many in the United States are still waiting for the Lumia Cyan update, most of the focus in the Windows Phone world is shifting to Lumia Denim. Currently, Lumia Denim comes installed on the Lumia 730, Lumia 735, and Lumia 830, with the Lumia 1520 and Lumia 930 slated to get an over-the-air update first, likely starting in the coming weeks.
This morning, a few fan sites began running articles about 'Lumia Emerald' alleging that it is the next firmware update following Denim. For now, I am calling these sightings a hoax for various reasons.
1. Too soon
Lumia Denim and Windows 10 development are the current focus for the Windows Phone teams. Lumia Denim still needs testing on older Lumia phones for its planned rollout, which could stretch into early 2015. The idea that the next update, which is not expected until sometime later in 2015, is out being tested already is a bit hard to swallow.
2. The alleged photo looks wrong
As usual with leaks, there is a photo to claim authenticity. Two things though, one it is very easy to make a screenshot in Photoshop, load it onto the phone and then take a terrible picture. In and of itself, a single photo does not mean anything.
Number 2, the photo cited as evidence seems a lot like the HTC One for Windows. See the above comparison with my HTC One loaded with, ahem, Lumia Denim.
3. No one has heard of it
I have checked with various sources familiar with Microsoft's development plans and they have never heard of Lumia Emerald. Sources can be wrong, of course, or just not know, but this casts doubt on the claim. For myself, this undermines the assertion that it is "getting tested in the wild" as surely many people would now know about it.
4. No codename
Looking at the previous firmware releases, we can see a distinct pattern in regards to public name versus internal codename.
This time, there is no codename, just the final Lumia + COLOR one. Doubtful.
5. Too obvious
Yesterday, many of you in comments were guessing 'Lumia Emerald' as the next iteration. It is somewhat an obvious color (although 'Evergreen' works too). The idea that someone would fake some screenshots with Lumia Emerald, perhaps to troll some sites, seem like something that would happen.
Interestingly, none of these sites claiming to know that it is Lumia Emerald knew about the Lumia Denim name. Maybe even more damaging, they cannot tell you what is in 'Lumia Emerald', just its name. Finally, it greatly helps to have a record of accomplishment on these things before anyone can take such assertions seriously.
In conclusion, the 'E' series of firmware could very well be called Emerald or Evergreen, or something else. For now though, there is no compelling reason to believe any of these stories.
Windows Central Newsletter
Get the best of Windows Central in your inbox, every day!
Daniel Rubino is the Editor-in-chief of Windows Central, head reviewer, podcast co-host, and analyst. He has been covering Microsoft since 2007 when this site was called WMExperts (and later Windows Phone Central). His interests include Windows, laptops, next-gen computing, and for some reason, watches. Before all this tech stuff, he worked on a Ph.D. in linguistics, watched people sleep (for medical purposes!), and ran the projectors at movie theaters because it was fun.
MS is just celebrating October Fools day
... Of course no one know right now we are waiting..... Thanks
-GDR2 for 8.1
-Lumia Cyan (some didn't even get it)
Elan Should be in there, I wager.
― Woody Allen
Can anybody tell me what is in Denim? I don't see anything new in denim on Lumia 830 compared to latest cyan on 930. Lumia Updates seem really to be a joke compared to updates of other systems but everybody is crazy about it without being able to tell say why.
If there is a second WP8.1 update this can probably be announced next month, being available for DP program, and be finally released in January/February. I guess most of phones will receive this even after the Windows 10 consumer preview be announced/released.
Just like LUMIA DEBIAN RED!!
like a darker hue of crimson, it is.
iOS and android are so gonna envy this.
those ratchet biatches ain't gettin this sh!t.
nuh-uh!!! *snap snap snap*
E-merald/vergreen (?) Surely I'm late to the party on this.