Both the Dell XPS 15 and Microsoft's newly announced Surface Pro (5th-gen) are gorgeous pieces of hardware, but which comes out on top for pricing and specs?
Microsoft took some time out in Shanghai, China to announce a new generation of Surface Pro. Instead of continuing with the current naming scheme, this latest Surface Pro will simply be called Surface Pro, dropping the "5". It's a big deal because while it may look like a Surface Pro 4 on the outside, it's a whole new device underneath the aluminum casing. With more than 800 new parts, redesigned thermal system, it's an incredibly versatile device.
The XPS 15 by Dell is one of the most recognizable Windows-powered PCs and the company played it safe with the recent refresh, as highlighted by Executive Editor Daniel Rubino in his review of the XPS 15 (9560). It's an absolute powerhouse of a laptop and is even viewed by Apple fans as the viable alternative should they wish to hop ship from OSX to Windows.
Technical jargon
Looking at the specifications for both options and it's easy to see just how close they can be. No matter which you choose to purchase you'll be partnering up with a capable Windows 10 PC.
| Category | Surface Pro | Dell XPS 15 (9560) |
|---|---|---|
| Operating System | Windows 10 Pro | Windows 10 Pro |
| CPU | 7th-gen Intel Core m3 7th-gen Intel Core i5 7th-gen Intel Core i7 |
7th-gen Intel Core i3 7th-gen Intel Core i5 7th-gen Intel Core i7 |
| Display | 112.3-inch Pixel Sense display 2736 x 1824 (267 PPI) |
15.6-inch 1080p matte non-touch 4K glossy touch |
| Storage | 128GB, 256GB, 512GB, or 1TB SSD | 500GB HDD + 32GB SSD 1TB HDD + 32GB SSD 256/512GB/1TB PCIe SSD |
| RAM | 4GB, 8GB or 16GB RAM 1866Mhz LPDDR3 |
8GB, 16GB, or 32GB 2400MHz DDR4 |
| GPU | Integrated | Integrated GTX 1050 (4GB GDDR5) |
| Rear Camera | 8MP Full HD (1920 x 1080) |
N/A |
| Front Camera | 5MP | 720p camera |
| Windows Hello | IR camera | Synaptics fingerprint reader |
| Dimensions | 11.50 inches x 7.9 inches x 0.33 inches (292 mm x 201 mm x 8.5 mm) |
14.06 inches x 9.27 inches x 0.45 – 0.66 inches (357mm x 235mm x 1-17mm) |
| Weight | 1.69 lbs to 1.73 lbs (768 g to 784 g) | 4 lbs (1.8 kg) |
| Ports | One full-size USB 3.0 Mini DisplayPort Headset jack Surface Connect microSDXC card reader |
HDMI 1.4 USB 3.0 (x2) with PowerShare Headset jack SD card reader (SD, SDHC, SDXC) Kensington Lock slot USB Type-C Thunderbolt 3 |
| WiFi | IEEE 802.11 a/b/g/n/ac compatible | Killer 1535 802.11a/b/g/n/ac |
| Battery | 13.5 hours | 10 hours |
| Pen | Surface Pen 4,096 levels of pressure sensitivity Magnetic storage |
N/A |
Important numbers
When it comes to pricing, the Surface Pro 2017 edition starts from just $799 and can cost as much as $2,699 depending on what options are selected. As for the Dell XPS 15, things kick off from $999.99 but can hit $2,549.99 if everything is set to "premium without compromise". A breakdown of the different configurations can be found below:
Microsoft Surface Pro
- 128 GB / Intel Core m3 / 4GB RAM - $799
- 128 GB / Intel Core i5 / 4GB RAM - $999
- 256 GB / Intel Core i5 / 8GB RAM - $1,299
- 256 GB / Intel Core i7 / 8GB RAM - $1,599
- 512 GB / Intel Core i7 / 16GB RAM - $2,199
- 1 TB / Intel Core i7 / 16GB RAM - $2,699
Dell XPS 15
- 500GB HDD, 32GB SSD / Intel Core i3 / 8GB RAM - $999.99
- 256GB SSD / Intel Core i5 / 8GB RAM - $1,349.99
- 512GB SSD / Intel Core i7 / 16GB RAM - $1,749.99
- 512GB SSD / Intel Core i7 / 16GB RAM / touch display - $2,149.99
Just how mobile are you?
Both are incredibly powerful machines, depending on which configuration you opt to pay for. The Surface Pro 4 is more of a portable tablet come notebook with more emphasis on being carried around, while the XPS 15 is a bulkier PC that focuses on getting even demanding tasks done. The choice one has to make between these two portable options depends largely on just how mobile they plan to be.
See the links below to make a purchase.
Reader comments
Surface Pro vs Dell XPS 15: Comparing two powerhouses
I think comparing the processors like they did in their chart isnvery misleading as the XPS15 has quadcore processors whereas the Surface uses Ultrabook Dualcore ones. this makes a huge difference performance wise. A better comparison would have been Surface Pro vs XPS13
I do wish you wouldn't just say "fingerprint scanner". Please specify touch or swipe. Every swipe version I've had has been unreliable in terms of recognition success ; every touch one has just worked.
The Dell is black. Batman would choose that over metal grey. Unless it was the 60's TV Batman.
Lol, still DDR3 in the Surface Pro? Even flagship Smartphones are already using DDR4...
Didn't mention that CPU in XPS are not ULV processor.
The Surface Pro's 112.3-inch Pixel Sense display is a bit unwieldy, but impressive, though the resolution could be higher...smirk
Stop comparing a fast assault boat with high tech fire control and guns with a destroyer. They simply don't serve the same purpose.
It seems the XPS 13 is the more appropriate comparison
Maybe
I have to say the jokes on the 112.3" in screen size have had me rolling and my sides now hurting :(
"512GB SSD / Intel Core i7 / 16GB RAM / touch display - $2,149.99"
The Dell XPS 9560 Core i7/512GB NVMe/16GB RAM 4K touch screen goes for $1600 @ Microcenter, which is strangely $300 less than most places
The specs aren't even complete.
XPS 15" uses quad core CPUs. SP5 uses NVe for the 1 TB SSD, not PCIe. The SP5 weight doesn't include keyboard.
Vocabulary error detected. This is not a comparison of two powerhouses. The Surface Pro is not a powerhouse - it is a tablet with, at most, a 15W dual-core CPU. Slow news life.
seems like Microsoft Hit the market with that 112.3-inch Pixel Sense Display
That 112.3" display on the Surface Pro is killer!
I have an XPS 9560 (i7/FHD) and an SP2. They are different horses for different courses and I am planning to upgrade my SP2 to something modern of similar weight and power down the road (E.g. Surface Pro/Laptop/Spectre x360t 13"). I get the gist of the comparo as most sane people would just want "one" device but it's hard to express the trade offs here easily. For someone that doesn't need the quad or the 32GB ram, it's hard to steer them to the XPS, it's pretty over the top device if you don't have use of that.
Why not SP5 instead of Laptop?
Why Surface Laptop vs Surface Pro? I'm open to either one. But neither would be able to do what a 7700-HQ and 32GB can so they are an addition, not a replacement.
Remove the "Surface Pen" from the comparison. It's not included with the box!
These aren't even comparable, might as well compare a tablet and a desktop.
Agree with you. One is 15.6 inch and other 112.3 inch. Completely incomparable 😁
Couple of typos...
Surface screen of 112.3 inches...
Last paragrapgh refers to the Surface Pro 4.
Silly comparison. These are different.
Dang, 112.3" is a huge screen on the Surface Pro. Not much of a tablet at that size 😉
comes with it's very own alcantara forklift!
I think the screen is 12.3" and not 112.3" on the Surface Pro
Typo 😂😂😂 one of the worst typos
But an 112-inch display would be awesome! Bring it Microsoft, TAKE MY MONEY!
😂😂😂
The tech specs table really needs to show this is an Ultrabook CPU vs a Laptop CPU as there's big differences, but each device has its own benefits over the other here.
An i5 is not an i5 though and it's not right to compare them just based on their designation like that
You are correct. They should be listing the processor part numbers as there are many i5's from which to choose. However, if one takes the time to read the i5 specs on Intel's site, you can narrow down and figure out which one the vendor chose to implement typically based on the on chip graphics. The important take-away is that they are indeed different and have different clock speeds.
I have the XPS 15 and I will probably be getting the Surface, but the XPS will be my main machine simply because it is quad core while the Surface Pro is only 2 core.
The pro for me. Portability is the secret word.
Power wise the XPS blows it out of the water, assuming they are still using the HQ processors, but the Surface destroys it on portability. I wouldn't call the surface a power house though
Dan as a gamer also, how do I know the VRAMs on these devices? I see they don't show that among specs nowadays but we all know those count in gaming too....be ut dedicated or integrated. Any idea?
For that form factor, the SP5 i7 is a powerhouse.
That's right! People who don't know what portability they can get from surface pro should never talk about it being pricey! It gives you way more then other devices. Plus the lte version ;")
What is the point of comparing incomparable things?
Fun 😂
to have one more windowscentral article /day
Unless one wants to discuss the pros and cos of smaller screen vs. larger screen, 2-in-1 vs. laptop, Surface vs. Dell, such a comparison is quite meaningless.
Makes not a lot of sense. SP vs. XPS13 ok, but vs. XPS 15?
It's like letting my Surface 3 (non-Pro) run vs. my gaming PC. Which one would win, I really could not tell.