Hard drive imaging vs. cloning: What's the difference?

Samsung 960 EVO
Samsung 960 EVO (Image credit: Windows Central)

Solid-state drives (SSD) are becoming all the rage thanks to the significant speed upgrade they deliver over standard hard-disk drives (HDD). Not only are SSDs faster, they're also more reliable because they don't have moving parts inside.

If you're swapping out a secondary drive, or one that doesn't contain your OS, you can technically just drag and drop the files you want to keep over to the new drive. But what about when you want to move your entire OS and your apps and your files to a new drive? That's where cloning and imaging come in. Let's take a look at what exactly each process involves, and why you might want to use each technique.

What is hard drive imaging?

Before you perform either process on your PC, it's good to know exactly what imaging and cloning are. They both involve creating a backup of your hard drive, but there are significant differences that make them suitable for different situations.

Imaging a hard drive is like creating a compressed file of your OS — all of the files needed to run Windows, plus anything you have saved on your hard drive, will be contained within the image, which is usually saved as an ISO file.

File History backs up to an external drive

Because of their compressed nature, multiple images can live on a single hard drive as long as there is space enough on the drive. This allows for multiple full, incremental, and differential backups to better keep your data safe.

What's the difference between these types of image backups? A full image takes everything on the drive and is required to restore your system. Differential backups keep a record of any changes made since the full image was created, so restoring a system requires the full image and the latest differential image.

Incremental images record any changes made since the last incremental image, so, in the case of a restoration, you need the full image and every incremental image created thereafter. Incremental images are sometimes preferred because they can be created quickly depending on how many changes have been made, whereas differential images can become quite large depending on how much time has gone by since a full image was created.

There are a few ways you can recover your computer using a drive image. If your Windows 10 PC suffers from a blue screen error and can't boot properly, you'll be confronted with a menu with an option to restore from a system image. In that case, you can choose your image (usually saved on an external drive) and restore your PC. Also, if you create a recovery environment on a separate USB stick or external hard drive, you can restore an image on a PC that doesn't have Windows 10 installed at all.

There doesn't need to be a complete failure, though, to benefit from an image backup. If you find that your computer has been infected with malware, for example, having a healthy image to restore to can make things quite easy when it comes to removing the virus.

What is hard drive cloning?

Since imaging a drive can seemingly keep tidy records of your files and can be used to put Windows on a new drive, where does cloning come in?

Unlike drive imaging, in which you create a compressed version of a drive that can be restored later, cloning creates an exact replica — boot records, files, settings and themes — that can be used immediately as a primary drive. This cloned drive can be kept as a backup, or you can reverse clone from it to a new, blank drive.

Use Macrium Reflect to clone your hard drive (Image credit: Windows Central)

For example, you can clone your PC's hard drive to an external drive, swap out the PC's internal drive for a new one, then boot from the external drive and reverse clone your OS and files back onto the new drive in your PC. If this seems a bit confusing, we wrote a guide on this process that lays everything out for you to digest:

How to clone your PC's hard drive

Because cloning creates an exact copy — no compression — of a hard drive, you can only clone to a hard drive once. You can, of course, overwrite the clone on the hard drive in the case that you need the external drive for other storage.

The examples above outline cloning using an external drive as an intermediary, but what about cloning directly? That's where a hard-drive enclosure comes is. These enclosures provide an environment similar to what is found inside a PC. That means you can connect hard drives meant for internal use through a USB port on your PC.

If you're swapping out your hard drive for something bigger and faster and don't want to deal with an intermediary external drive, you can grab an inexpensive enclosure, pop your new drive into it, clone directly onto it, and install it in your PC. Because of the nature of cloning, the newly installed drive should boot just as though nothing had been changed, and you'll find Windows exactly as you left it.

Conclusion and more resources

To recap, imaging a drive is best suited for keeping backups of your OS and files — you can store multiple images on a single drive and you can schedule incremental and differential backups — but it can also be used when upgrading the hard drive in your PC.

Cloning a drive is more suited for times when you're upgrading your hard drive — with an external enclosure, it's basically just a one-step process — but it can also be used in a backup situation. If your hard drive crashes and you have a recently cloned version laying around, you can simply pop it into your PC and act like nothing happened.

If you're still seeking additional related resources, we've got you covered:

Cale Hunt
Senior Editor, Laptop Reviews

Cale Hunt is a Senior Editor at Windows Central. He focuses mainly on laptop reviews, news, and accessory coverage. He's been reviewing laptops and accessories full time since 2016, with hundreds of reviews published for Windows Central. He is an avid PC gamer and multi-platform user, and spends most of his time either tinkering with or writing about tech.

  • Simple, clone, a clone drive can be accessed by any PC it's connected to. An image has to be flashed back to a drive. I clone hards drive all day for my job where we use PCs to run an automated market. Needeach PC to have the same server software running on them. Cuts 6 hrs of setup out of each market down to a 10 mins clone.
  • Windows 7's full system image backups can be browsed in 7-Zip, although I haven't tried opening incremental images.
  • Or just in file explorer. I've mounted the vhd file and accessed files from there
  • Can you boot from it? I use a Samsung T3 500 GB and can boot from the clone as it's just a "copy" of the original. Well, depends on the computer. I've seen some PC's that will BSoD booting from a USB clone. Depends on the motherboard/bios. In fact just had a hard drive fail on a coding server running a vertual box. One PC would boot from the Samsung T3, the other BSoD, but would go into safe mode. Either way, saved the day by cloning the failing hard drive and cloning it back onto a new har drive. Saving days of work setting up the whole vrtualmachine all over again.
  • Now you can use docker!
  • Clonning also clones the free space on the drive.
  • Yes, that's a very important difference. If you are copying a drive that is nearly full, cloning definitely makes more sense. But empty drives probably better to image.
  • Acronis deals with this very well by expanding for the new drive. Other wise if you clone your drive, you go into Disk managment, find your OS drive and expand as needed.
  • Does anyone know any opensource software for files back and imaging all together in one software.
    I need a solution where ones computer's files can be backed up on amazon storage so that if the person deletes any files on their comouter or the drive fails they can view individually or choose individually which files to downlaod (from amazon storage that i will provide).
    Also at the same time an image can be made on the amazon storage because in an image you can not choose or view the files individually.
    Any suggestions????
  • Macrium Reflect and I believe Acronis also lets you adjust the size of the partitions when you clone so you don't end up with a bunch of free space when moving to a newer, larger hard drive.
  • Thanks for the article
  • I recently ran into oddities with cloning my C drive when upgrading from an HDD to SSD. The SSD was also bigger, and the cloning software wouldn't let me expand it to use up the entire new drive as the C drive, so I had to create a new drive/partition to make use of the extra space. What gives?
  • Can I ask what software you were using?
  • What enclosure are you guys using to clone to the 960 EVO.  I can't find an enclosure that actually accepts  NVMe PCIe gen 3 SSDs like hte 960 EVO/Pro.  I tried buying a more expensive one but it turns that one also does not support the 950/960 SSDs. 
  • Really informative, article 🙂
    I was lost half way through, mixing imaging with ghosting, but your summary at the end saved me 😀