How to choose the best router

Our connected reality means that the devices we use every day are becoming "smart" and joining our home networks. Whereas just a few years ago a home router commonly had just a phone, PC, and maybe a tablet connected, you'll often now find more connections than you can count on two hands. Streaming TV, making calls, dimming lights, and adjusting the temperature in your place is all handled over wireless internet, provided by a Wi-Fi router.

Why shop for a specific router?

Why shop for a specific router?

Because of its important role in a connected home, choosing a proper router is becoming more important than ever before. Most internet service providers (ISP) will supply you with a wireless router — often coupled with a cable or DSL modem — and many people assume that it's as good as it gets. It connects your devices to the internet, so why worry?

In some cases, the router provided by your ISP will indeed serve you well and you'll be satisfied with what you have, especially if it's loaned to you as part of the subscription package. For years I lived in a small, open place that easily picked up my few devices with the single antenna, and when I needed to hit a top speed, I used an Ethernet cable. If, however, you're having to rent a router from your ISP, or if it's outdated compared to the devices you're using in your home, you can likely take advantage of an upgrade.

See the best Wi-Fi routers in 2018

Wi-Fi 802.11 a/b/g/n/ac standards

Wi-Fi is a global standard, and to ensure that devices can connect without issue, there are specifications that it must adhere to. That standard is known as 802.11, and the letters a, b, g, n, or ac following designate the version. The versions are all compatible with each other, but connecting to an earlier version means your device will be capped at the slower speed.

Wi-Fi has not stopped evolving, and AC is currently the latest version, though N-version devices and routers are still relevant and quite common. However, because of the progression, buying a new 802.11n router in most cases doesn't make as much sense as buying an AC router, especially because of how much they've dropped in price. New devices are going the way of AC, and it's smart to look to the future.

Single-band vs. dual-band

Single-band vs. dual-band

Wireless communication happens over frequency bands, which can be seen as roads that your data travel along. While routers up to and including 802.11g operated solely on the 2.4GHz band, support for a 5GHz band was added in 802.11n and carried over to 802.11ac (which operates on the 5GHz band). Why? The 2.4GHz band was becoming crowded, leading to a rush hour scenario where traffic was getting jammed up.

Devices that can use only the 2.4GHz band are called single-band devices, while dual-band devices can use the 2.4GHz and 5GHz bands. Whereas the lower-frequency band has a lower speed limit and is more narrow, the 5GHz band is much wider and has a much higher speed limit.

There are drawbacks to the 5GHz band. Higher frequency means the signal loses more of its strength as it deals with walls, furniture, and other obstacles, though AC routers have something called beamforming that will send a signal in the direction of a device, rather than just spraying a signal in a sphere around it. Still, the increased speed and wider road mean it's perfect for streaming high-def video and gaming.

Simultaneous dual-band routers should be what you're looking for, as they offer both bands at once. Why limit yourself to just one?

Consider your internet's top speed

Consider your internet's top speed

Within each Wi-Fi standard are further classifications that determine the actual performance you'll get. You might see a router advertised as AC1200 or N600, but that doesn't mean you're getting a top speed of 1200Mbps or 600Mbps. This number is a combination of speeds from both bands. For example, an AC1200 router is going to have a 2.4GHz band with a top speed of 300Mbps and a 5GHz band with a top speed of 867Mbps (rounded up to the nearest hundred).

Even these speeds are theoretical, and in real-world testing you likely won't get anywhere near that number. Likewise, if you see a router labeled with something like AC5000, it's not magically hitting 5000Mbps. Instead, you're getting a single 600Mbps 2.4GHz band and two 2166Mbps 5GHz bands.

So, stepping out and buying the biggest, baddest, most expensive router might be tempting, but paying for something you don't need will be more of a letdown. For example, if you're paying for a 50Mbps internet plan from your ISP and you live in a one-bedroom apartment, it doesn't make much sense to buy an AC5000 router with eight antennas. Your internet can only be as fast as the slowest point in the connection, which in this case is likely what's provided by your ISP.

Determine how much area you need to cover

Determine how much area you need to cover

Living in a large home can cause problems when it comes to serving Wi-Fi to all of your devices, especially when using the 5GHz band. For smaller apartments or homes, a single router with a strong set of antennas will no doubt get the job done, and it doesn't hurt to test things out before buying something too expensive. Reading reviews is a great way to get an idea of how much range a router has. You can also always check out Wi-Fi extenders that pick up a router's signal and rebroadcast it somewhere else in your home.

Best Wi-Fi Extenders for Improved In-Home Coverage

If you know you're going to have an issue covering a large space and don't want to buy a single, large router, you can always take a look at mesh Wi-Fi kits. These work in unison to deliver Wi-Fi to a large area, often covering thousands of square feet of indoor space.

Best Mesh Wi-Fi Router Kits of 2018

Count how many devices need to connect

Count how many devices need to connect

If you're living alone and have but a few devices that would be connected at once — a console along with a phone, or a laptop along with a TV streaming device — you shouldn't have to worry about putting too much strain on your router. While you shouldn't ever hit a point where you can no longer connect devices (unless you're supplying internet for the entire block), the more connections you have at once will slow speeds.

If you have a router with a 2.4GHz band that can hit a theoretical max of 300Mbps and have 10 devices connected at once, each of those devices would only be getting an average of about 30Mbps. For anyone in a crowded home with multiple devices connected at once, a high-end, dual-band router is your best bet. If your family can't stop streaming Netflix, a tri-band router with two 5GHz bands is definitely something to consider.

On that note, pay attention to how many Ethernet ports a router has. Have lots of devices for which you want to provide a wired connection? Start counting. Likewise, check for USB ports if you're looking to add an external drive or other device to your home network.

Do you need MU-MIMO?

Do you need MU-MIMO?

To complicate things even further, some new routers have something called multi-user, multiple-input, multiple-output (MU-MIMO) tech baked right in. Whereas more traditional single-user, multiple-input, multiple-output (SU-MIMO) tech delivers data to one device at a time on a rotating basis, MU-MIMO allows for simultaneous data delivery.

SU-MIMO is fine for most purposes, and the rotating delivery happens so fast you usually won't notice. If, however, someone in the home is streaming video and you're trying to game online, MU-MIMO can come in handy by offering uninterrupted data flows to both devices.

Those devices must have MU-MIMO capabilities, and while that number is growing, your older stuff likely won't be able to benefit. Check out our guide to MU-MIMO for much more information.

What is MU-MIMO and why would you need it?

Consider software and security features

Consider software and security features

If you need to be in full control of everything that goes through your router, go for one with advanced firmware that includes a decent firewall and offers any additional features you may require, or supports the installation of third-party advanced firmware like DD-WRT that can offer those features.

If you are concerned about your children being exposed to inappropriate information on the internet, choosing a router with built-in parental controls can be useful. Some routers even let you allow and restrict internet access for your children based on time slots and offer guest access for your visitors so that you won't need to provide them with your primary Wi-Fi password.

TL;DR

Now that I've thrown all these terms and acronyms at you, I'll do a bit of a recap. An AC router is your best bet for a future-proof connection, though an N router can be had for dirt cheap and is likely suitable if you aren't paying for a high-speed connection from your ISP. If you are paying for a high-speed connection, ensure you're investing in a router that can handle it. You want to extend that speed to all your devices, whether with a dual-band or even tri-band router.

Consider how big of a space you need to cover, and plan accordingly. Some of the high-end routers can tackle a pretty impressive chunk of real estate, but you might need to invest in a range extender to hit that bottom corner of the basement. There are also mesh router kits that you might want to consider, which set out from the start to hit every nook and cranny.

If you are in a big space, you might have a lot of people trying to connect their devices simultaneously. If this is the case, investing in a router with two 5GHz bands isn't a bad idea, and going for something with a high speed might come in handy if you decide to upgrade your ISP internet package in the future. Likewise, a router with MU-MIMO is looking to the future.

Finally, choose a router with the proper customization options. If you want to tweak a lot of settings, ensure it makes them available to you. If you'd rather just plug it in and not worry about it, you'll probably have an easier time when shopping.