“Why can ThinkPads do this but Surface can’t?” — A perfect repair score exposes Microsoft’s hardware gap

Lenovo unveiled the ThinkPad T14 Gen 7 earlier this year at Mobile World Congress. The commercial laptop is the successor to the well-known T490 and looks to be a fixture in offices after it starts shipping.

The ThinkPad T14 Gen 7 packs the latest processors from Intel and AMD, but it's what's surrounding those chips that drew headlines. Just one day after being announced, the laptop received a perfect repairability score from iFixit.

That score likely came as little surprise to iFixit, since the company was consulted about the ThinkPad T14's design. But the 10/10 may have spooked Microsoft's Surface team.

The Surface Laptop 7 is the most repairable Surface Laptop to date, but it now sits behind the ThinkPad T14 Gen 7 by a wide margin.

The cost of improving repairability

After seeing the headline of this piece, you might have asked, "But isn't the Surface Laptop 7 rather repairable?" You'd be right in thinking that the Surface Laptop 7 is easier to repair than its predecessors, but it falls far short of what Lenovo has done with the ThinkPad T14 Gen 7.

iFixit called the original Surface Laptop a "glue-filled monster," but things have improved since Gen 1. The Surface Laptop 7 is easy to open, has an easily replaceable battery, and supports easy access to the M.2 SSD for swapping.

The Surface Laptop 7 received an 8/10 from iFixit for repairability. While impressive, that rating is two entire points short of what the ThinkPad T14 Gen 7 received.

Two points may sound small, but look at what iFixit said about increasing a repairability score by just a single point (emphasis added):

"Going from a high score to the highest score isn’t usually about making minor tweaks. It requires fighting for every small, boring, consequential decision—the ones that determine whether a repair isn’t merely possible or practical, but within easy reach. We cheered Lenovo on as they pushed beyond “great,” kept refining, and arm-wrestled every last tenth of a repairability point into submission."

Lenovo explained that it had to shift its mindset during the design process to make the ThinkPad T14 Gen 7 more repairable. The PC maker noted to iFixit that serviceability is usually optimized later in development, but Lenovo had to move that forward to an earlier stage.

iFixit highlighted several repairability aspects of the ThinkPad T14 Gen 7. Here's a quick rundown of how the Surface Laptop 7 stacks up:

We'll have to wait to see if the Surface Laptop 8 fills any of these gaps and competes directly with the ThinkPad T14 Gen 7 in terms of repairability.

Why this matters for Surface

Microsoft has either streamlined or stripped down its Surface lineup, depending on your perspective. The days of wacky form factors appear to be behind us. Instead, Microsoft is focused on its traditional clamshell laptop, the Surface Laptop, and the Surface Pro that inspired the modern 2-in-1.

When a company makes laptops with unique hinges, detachable displays, and a GPU in the keyboard, people can let some things slide (the Surface Book 2 received a 1/10 from iFixit).

But considering Microsoft is focused on just two form factors, the tech giant needs to nail those down and meet the bar set by other OEMs.

Lenovo has already become what Surface was supposed to be about in terms of unique hardware. Microsoft can't afford to trail in more categories.

One of the top complaints about the Surface Laptop 7 is its battery expanding. Images of swollen batteries are far too common on social media.

We also saw the Surface Laptop 7 listed as a frequently returned item by Amazon last year, though the retailer did not provide specifics.

The r/sysadmin subreddit has a thread full of people complaining about Surface Laptops, including swollen batteries in those PCs. It’s anecdotal, but the pattern is consistent: multiple admins reporting fleets of Surface devices with battery expansion issues.

While it is possible to replace the battery of the Surface Laptop 7, doing so on the ThinkPad T14 Gen 7 is much easier.

On r/thinkpad, repairability isn’t just appreciated, it’s part of the culture. People love how repairable and modular ThinkPads are. It's one of the many reasons the laptops have a passionate and dedicated following.

The subreddit is full of posts showing decade‑old ThinkPads revived with new batteries or keyboards, users swapping parts in minutes, and people praising Lenovo for finally making USB‑C ports modular after years of frustration with soldered connectors.

Microsoft needs to make the Surface Laptop stand out. To do that, it needs to build a Surface Laptop from the ground up with repairability in mind.

Join us on Reddit at r/WindowsCentral to share your insights and discuss our latest news, reviews, and more.