Former Xbox 360 boss Peter Moore publicly shuts down Xbox co‑founder’s criticism of new CEO Asha Sharma, basically calling the 'gamer CEO' argument nonsense

Peter Moore is one of the most respected figures to ever lead the Xbox brand. Before becoming a familiar public face for the platform, he helped guide the original Xbox through its difficult early years and then played a major role in shaping the Xbox 360 era — the period many fans still view as Xbox’s high point.

Moore left Microsoft in 2007 to take on a senior leadership role at Electronic Arts, but his impact on Xbox’s identity and momentum remains a major part of the brand’s legacy.

After Moore left, Don Mattrick took over, and we all know how that chapter played out. But that’s not what this is about.

In a new interview with GamesBeat, Moore sat down to discuss a range of topics. More importantly for Xbox fans, he shared his thoughts on the new Xbox CEO, offering words for the Xbox co-founder who had less than nice things to say about Xbox, and he also had some encouraging advice for Asha Sharma, the new CEO.

Peter Moore on Asha Sharma — “Listen and learn”

In the interview, Peter Moore reflects on his own unconventional path into gaming. He compares his move from Reebok into SEGA, and later Xbox, to Asha Sharma stepping in from a non-gaming background.

“That was me at Sega. I’d come from Reebok, if you remember. I was a shoe guy.”

Moore makes it clear that being an outsider is not automatically a weakness. In fact, he suggests that feeling overwhelmed is part of the process.

Still, he offers practical advice rather than criticism.

Moore also acknowledges that Sharma’s AI background could complicate things, especially with gamers who are wary of anything AI-related.

“She’s gotta explain AI and her background. That’s a minefield. I would, for me, avoid talking about that if you possibly can. But I wish her all the best.”

Of course, Moore was not the only industry veteran speaking to GamesBeat. Xbox co-founder Seamus Blackley also weighed in, bluntly stating in a prior interview, “Xbox is being sunsetted.” However, he did clarify later that he doesn't think Xbox is dead.

Moore does not attack Blackley or anything, but he clearly disagrees.

“I saw Seamus’s comments. I hope he’s a little misguided.”

What stands out throughout the interview is Moore’s tone. He is very calm and grounded. It is hard not to miss that kind of leadership presence.

He also makes a point of defending Phil Spencer, the former head of Xbox and gaming at Microsoft.

It’s a lengthy interview with GamesBeat, so prepare yourselves, but I’ve done my best to organise it in a clear and digestible way.

It’s genuinely refreshing to see Moore weigh in on these topics with such a measured tone. He has nothing but thoughtful, constructive things to say, which feels like a welcome change from what often passes as commentary these days.

🗨️ Where do you land on the “gamer CEO” debate after Moore’s pushback?

Peter Moore didn’t just disagree with Seamus Blackley — he torched the whole “gamer CEO” argument as outdated, unhelpful, and completely beside the point. His defense of Asha Sharma is basically a reminder that Xbox needs leadership, not gatekeeping, and that the industry has evolved far beyond “must have X hours in Halo to qualify.”

It’s rare to see an Xbox veteran step in this forcefully, and it says a lot about where the real fault lines are right now.

So let’s hear it: was Moore right to shut this down, or does the “gamer CEO” test still matter to you? Jump in and tell us how you see this debate — especially now that one of Xbox’s most respected leaders has weighed in so bluntly.

Join us on Reddit at r/WindowsCentral to share your insights and discuss our latest news, reviews, and more.